Papalocal
Loading…
News
← All news
Politics

Five new Democratic trifectas could push Electoral College workaround over the finish line

The National Popular Vote Interstate Compact is 48 electoral votes short of activation — and five newly flipped states hold exactly 61.

How does this story make you feel?

For two decades, a plan to make the national popular vote winner the president — without touching a word of the Constitution — has inched forward state by state. After this month's elections, it is closer than it has ever been, and the people running it say they have never been more confident it will be in place for 2028.

The National Popular Vote Interstate Compact now has 18 states and Washington, D.C. as members, representing 222 combined electoral votes. The compact only activates when member states collectively hold at least 270 electoral votes — an absolute majority of the Electoral College. That leaves it 48 votes short. Democrats this cycle won new governing trifectas in six states; five of them — Arizona, Michigan, Nevada, Pennsylvania, and Wisconsin — are not yet compact members and together hold 61 electoral votes. If all five join, the compact would reach 283 electoral votes and trigger. According to Democracy Docket, if they do so by July 20, 2028, the compact would be in effect for the next presidential election.

Lawmakers in all five states introduced compact legislation in 2025 or 2026, according to Ballotpedia, and multiple Democratic legislators have said they plan to do so again. Even four of the five states could clear the threshold — as long as Michigan and Pennsylvania, the two largest, are among them, according to Ballotpedia.

Several of the incoming governors and legislative leaders have already signaled support. Wisconsin Gov.-elect David Crowley told the Associated Press he was 'interested in having those conversations with the state Legislature.' Pennsylvania Gov. Josh Shapiro said he would work with lawmakers on the question, though he noted Pennsylvania's identity as a swing state: 'I think Pennsylvania can still play a massive role even in a national popular vote.' Nevada Gov.-elect Aaron Ford said he would support joining the compact. Arizona Senate President-elect Priya Sundareshan told Politico her caucus was prepared to join. Arizona Gov. Katie Hobbs and Michigan Gov.-elect Jocelyn Benson have not publicly commented since the election, according to Ballotpedia.

National popular vote will be something that we'll prioritize early in the session.— Kelda Roys, Wisconsin state senator (D)

The compact works by having each member state pass a law pledging its electoral votes to whichever presidential candidate wins the most votes nationally — regardless of the outcome within that state. Those state laws lie dormant until enough states have signed on to constitute a 270-vote majority, at which point they all activate simultaneously. Sixteen of the 18 states that have already adopted the compact were Democratic trifectas when they enacted the legislation, according to Ballotpedia.

The political logic behind the compact is straightforward: it would have changed the outcome of the 2000 and 2016 presidential elections, when George W. Bush and Donald Trump respectively won the Electoral College while receiving fewer votes than their Democratic opponents, according to Democracy Docket. A poll from Data for Progress, shared exclusively with Democracy Docket, found 62% of likely voters think the national popular vote winner should become president, versus 31% who prefer the Electoral College. That includes 76% of Democrats, 60% of independents, and 47% of Republicans — a plurality, though 45% of Republicans backed the Electoral College.

Despite that cross-partisan voter support, Republican officials have largely opposed the compact. Patrick Rosenstiel, a GOP political operative and senior consultant to the NPV campaign, argues his fellow Republicans are wrong to fear it. He says the compact would force presidential candidates to campaign everywhere rather than concentrating on battleground states — pointing to voter turnout in 2024 running 11% higher in swing states than elsewhere.

We believe that every voter, in every precinct, in every state should be politically relevant — equally relevant — in presidential elections. And we want to put voters back in charge of presidential elections, not courts in battleground states — through hair-splitting lawsuits — determining who wins or loses these pretty important elections.— Patrick Rosenstiel, senior consultant, National Popular Vote campaign

The compact's biggest obstacle may not be in state legislatures but in federal courts. Legal scholars have raised questions about whether an interstate compact of this scale would require congressional consent — a requirement that, if imposed by the Supreme Court, could kill the effort or at minimum delay it. Akhil Reed Amar, the Yale University law professor credited with originating the compact idea, now worries that attempting to enact it could lead to a constitutional crisis, according to Democracy Docket.

Rosenstiel is dismissive of those concerns, arguing the case law on interstate compacts and the Presidential Electors Clause supports the compact's constitutionality — and that the current Supreme Court, based on a series of essentially unanimous decisions going back more than a century, would uphold it. He also argues that even if the Court required congressional approval, Democrats currently control both chambers and could pass a concurrent resolution — which is not subject to a presidential veto. And he notes that Trump himself once called the Electoral College a 'disaster,' leaving open the possibility he might sign a statute if one were required.

Whether I believe it, you believe it, pick your favorite Harvard Law professor agrees with it – is irrelevant. What they decide is relevant.— Patrick Rosenstiel, senior consultant, National Popular Vote campaign

The next steps are concrete and time-sensitive. State legislatures in Arizona, Michigan, Nevada, Pennsylvania, and Wisconsin would need to pass compact legislation and have it signed by their governors. The July 20, 2028 deadline — roughly 18 months away — sets the outer limit for the compact to apply to the next presidential election. Whether all five states move, or only some, will determine whether the compact crosses the threshold, falls short again, or lands somewhere in between.

Why it matters — If five newly Democratic-controlled states pass compact legislation before mid-2028, the Electoral College could effectively be sidelined for the next presidential election — without a constitutional amendment — though legal challenges at the Supreme Court would almost certainly follow.

⚠ Not yet confirmed

  • Arizona Gov. Katie Hobbs and Michigan Gov.-elect Jocelyn Benson have not publicly commented since the election on whether they would support joining the compact.
  • Trump once called the Electoral College a 'disaster,' leaving open the possibility he might sign compact-related legislation.
  • incorrect source_host attribution for Kelda Roys quote

Reported by ballotpedia.org, news.ballotpedia.org, democracydocket.com

People in this story

Community

Be the first to comment.

Share this story
Text Email