Papalocal
Loading…
News
← All news
Your Money

Retired couple's Medicare bill triples after move to a Minnesota county losing all Advantage plans

Steve and Sarah Myhro relocated to Crow Wing County to be near family — and discovered their $2,900-a-year Medicare Advantage plan will vanish in 2027, replaced by $9,000-plus in alternatives.

How does this story make you feel?

Steve Myhro, 71, a retired teacher, and his wife Sarah, 68, a professional violinist, moved from Rochester, New York, to Nisswa in Crow Wing County, Minnesota, about a year and a half ago to be closer to family. They budgeted carefully. What they did not budget for was a $7,000-a-year jump in Medicare costs — a consequence of where, precisely, they chose to build their house.

Starting in 2027, Crow Wing County will have no Medicare Advantage plans available at all. The Blue Cross Blue Shield of Minnesota plan the Myhros relied on — which covered both of them for $2,900 a year — is being withdrawn. With no competing plans to fill the gap, their insurance broker recommended switching to Original Medicare supplemented by a HealthPartners Medigap policy and a separate prescription drug plan. The projected annual cost: more than $9,000.

It's going to cost us over $9,000 a year instead of less than $3,000.— Steve Myhro, retired teacher

The geographic arbitrariness of the situation is not lost on Myhro. Crow Wing County's neighbors — Cass and Aitkin — are not losing their Medicare Advantage options in 2027.

I could have built the house five miles away in Cass County and not be experiencing these kinds of increases. To me, that just makes no sense.— Steve Myhro, retired teacher

The Myhros are not alone. Across Minnesota, seniors in Crow Wing, Wadena, and Lake of the Woods counties will have no Medicare Advantage options in 2027, according to MPR News. An additional 15 Minnesota counties will lose Medicare Advantage plans, though Medicare cost plans and Original Medicare remain available there. Statewide, 1.2 million Medicare enrollees will face a reduced set of choices.

Medicare Advantage — sometimes called MA or Part C — is the private-plan alternative to Original Medicare, administered by insurers and available only at the county level. Plans can include prescription drug coverage, dental, vision, and fitness benefits, often at lower premiums than traditional Medicare plus supplemental coverage. But insurers can withdraw from individual counties, and they have been doing so at an accelerating pace.

Nationally, 187 counties will have no Medicare Advantage plans of any kind in 2027, according to an analysis by KFF. A related figure: 193 counties will have no Medicare Advantage prescription drug plans — up sharply from 123 counties in 2026. KFF estimates this will affect roughly 638,000 Americans, or about 1 percent of all Medicare beneficiaries. The affected counties span 16 states, including Alaska, where no Medicare Advantage prescription drug plans are offered in any county.

Insurers attribute the withdrawals to rising medical and pharmaceutical costs, financial losses, and the difficulty of maintaining provider networks in rural areas, according to reporting by both Yahoo Finance and MPR News.

Nicole Converse, a broker at RG Insurance in Baxter, Minnesota, has seen the impact firsthand. In prior years, she said, seniors in Crow Wing and Wadena counties could find Medicare Advantage plans with monthly premiums ranging from $0 to about $120. For 2027, more comprehensive alternatives can run more than $400 a month.

Now they have to pay how much money to still not go to the doctor or take the risk and say, 'I'm just going to take original Medicare, and hopefully I don't get sick, and hopefully something doesn't happen.' That's not the point of Medicare.— Nicole Converse, broker, RG Insurance

Wadena County, which is also losing all Medicare Advantage options, ranks among Minnesota's lowest-income counties. Converse said some residents there rely almost entirely on Social Security, making even modest supplemental premiums unaffordable.

To show someone a plan of over $300 … it's their entire Social Security check.— Nicole Converse, broker, RG Insurance

Converse's agency has hundreds of clients on a waiting list and is organizing group educational events while seniors wait for individual appointments. She cautioned that there is no guarantee Medicare Advantage options will return to affected counties in future years.

Myhro has written to U.S. Rep. Pete Stauber and Gov. Tim Walz. A response dated Nov. 4 from Walz's office pointed to the governor's reinsurance program and legislation intended to protect insurance access, cited federal healthcare changes under the Trump administration, and encouraged Myhro to contact state legislators. Stauber's office said the congressman was reviewing Myhro's comments and that 'his voice has been heard,' according to MPR News.

Myhro says the issue extends well beyond his own household. At coffee gatherings in Nisswa and Pequot Lakes, he has spoken with retirees in their 90s who have serious medical conditions and cannot afford supplemental coverage.

Those are the people I hurt for.— Steve Myhro, retired teacher
I really want to know why we as seniors are having to bear so much of the cost of this kind of market restructuring.— Steve Myhro, retired teacher

For enrollees whose Medicare Advantage plan has been discontinued, a Special Enrollment Period runs from Dec. 8 through the end of February, giving extra time to select new coverage — though this can leave gaps at the start of the year. Medicare's standard annual enrollment period ends Dec. 7, with changes taking effect Jan. 1. Enrollees who do nothing will default to Original Medicare Parts A and B but must separately enroll in Part D to retain prescription drug coverage. Those whose MA plan is discontinued may qualify for guaranteed-issue Medigap rights, meaning insurers cannot deny coverage or charge more based on health conditions. The State Health Insurance Assistance Program (SHIP) offers free one-on-one counseling.

Why it matters — As insurers pull Medicare Advantage plans from rural counties across 16 states, hundreds of thousands of seniors on fixed incomes face abrupt, large cost increases with little warning — and the county-by-county patchwork means a move of just a few miles can determine whether someone pays $3,000 or $9,000 a year for the same basic coverage.

⚠ Not yet confirmed

  • Some retirees in their 90s whom Myhro has spoken with in Nisswa and Pequot Lakes have serious medical conditions and face costs that 'will bankrupt them.'
  • Rep. Pete Stauber's office said the congressman was reviewing Myhro's comments and 'his voice has been heard.'

Reported by yahoo.com, finance.yahoo.com, moneywise.com, mprnews.org

People in this story

Community

Be the first to comment.

Share this story
Text Email