Papalocal
Loading…
News
← All news
Community

FAIR Conference 2026: LDS apologists tackle miracles, Brigham Young, and how to spot a reliable source

Scholars, historians, and content creators gathered in Lehi, Utah this week to wrestle publicly with some of the hardest questions in Latter-day Saint history and doctrine.

How does this story make you feel?

Source: deseret.com

A crowd of Latter-day Saint scholars, believers, and apologists filled a conference hall in Lehi, Utah on Thursday — the second of three days at FAIR Conference 2026 — and the questions on the table were not small ones: How did Joseph Smith actually translate the Book of Mormon? Was Brigham Young the tyrant his critics describe? And when a church member encounters a troubling historical claim online, how do they know whether to trust it?

FAIR — which stands for Faithful Answers, Informed Response — has run this annual conference for years as a venue where Latter-day Saint apologists, historians, and educators can address faith challenges head-on, in public, with primary sources in hand. The 2026 edition drew BYU religion professors, Church History Department researchers, and others.

The atmosphere was less lecture hall than community gathering — attendees engaged during presentations, the kind of crowd that shows up precisely because these topics matter to them personally.

Researcher Gerrit Dirkmaat set the tone early in a presentation on the Book of Mormon translation, drawing a line between scholarly inquiry and the limits of explaining the miraculous.

I can’t describe to you exactly how Joseph and Oliver translated the Book of Mormon, any more than I can tell you precisely how the molecules of water behave when Jesus steps on them to walk across. Miracles, by their definition, are beyond explanation. That is the reason we believe in them — because they cannot happen any other way than by the power of God.— Gerrit Dirkmaat, Latter-day Saint researcher

It was a framing that threaded through much of the day: acknowledge what scholarship can and cannot do, then be honest about both. That same spirit animated Brett Dowdle's presentation on Brigham Young, a figure whose reputation has taken sustained hits in popular culture and in some corners of Mormon studies. Dowdle, a historian in the Church History Department who has worked on the Joseph Smith Papers, argued the documentary record tells a more complicated story.

As Latter-day Saints become increasingly familiar with the Brigham Young who appears in the documents, they will discover a multifaceted man who, although not perfect, was far from the caricature that so many have imagined him to be.— Brett Dowdle, historian, Church History Department

Dowdle also cited the recollection of Young's daughter Susa, who described a father who was never harsh nor unjustly severe and whom his children obeyed because they loved him, according to Deseret News.

The question of how to evaluate sources — any sources — got its own dedicated treatment from Keith Erekson, a researcher at the Church History Department, who offered a working definition of fairness that cuts across religious and secular discourse alike.

Fairness represents sympathetically the viewpoints of multiple and equally opposing perspectives. If the subject of the treatment recognizes him or herself, then it is probably fair. If the author belittles other perspectives or emphasizes emotion, polarization and estrangements, then fairness has been compromised.— Keith Erekson, researcher, Church History Department

Erekson also noted that antagonism toward faith in public discourse revels in pointing out anomalies, taking things out of context, mounting long lists to produce information overload, alleging conspiracies, and reducing complex realities to false choices, according to Deseret News.

Casey Griffiths, a BYU religion professor and co-host of the Church History Matters podcast, addressed the practical problem of distinguishing official church teaching from folk theology — a distinction that matters enormously when someone is trying to decide whether a troubling claim represents what the church actually teaches.

Before we claim that the church teaches something, we need to be more careful about our claims. Before we say something is an official teaching in the church, we need to run it through a couple models.— Casey Griffiths, BYU religion professor

Griffiths described two frameworks he uses with students: one for identifying reliable sources such as current correlated church publications, cumulative teachings of church officers, harmonized scripture, and the united voice of prophets and apostles, and one for categorizing gospel truths into core eternal doctrines, supporting teachings, policy teachings, and esoteric teachings — with core doctrines being relatively few in number, per Deseret News.

Jasmin Rappleye, a Latter-day Saint content creator and scholar, took on one of the most persistent misconceptions about the faith from outside observers: that Latter-day Saint temple worship is works-based, a kind of spiritual transaction rather than a covenant relationship rooted in grace.

In a Latter-day Saint temple, yes, we make covenants and we promise to take those covenants very seriously. But the temple is also crystal clear that it is only through the sacrifice of Jesus Christ that we are saved. The promises we make help us emulate and become more like Jesus Christ. But I believe all the symbols that are associated with our covenants are there as vivid reminders that it is only through the grace and sacrifice — the infinite, eternal sacrifice — of Jesus Christ that we are saved.— Jasmin Rappleye, Latter-day Saint content creator and scholar

The day closed with historian Janiece Johnson, who specializes in the Mountain Meadows massacre — the 1857 event in which a wagon train of emigrants was killed in southern Utah, one of the most painful episodes in early Latter-day Saint history. Her argument was methodological as much as historical.

Context is going to change everything. When we look at the most complicated pieces of our history, we need experts' help.— Janiece Johnson, historian

Johnson noted that one person cannot do what an entire department can, and framed institutional historical work as evidence of willingness to wrestle with difficult things rather than dismiss them, according to Deseret News.

FAIR Conference is one of the longest-running venues for Latter-day Saint apologetics — the practice of defending religious claims through reasoned argument and evidence. The field has grown considerably as the internet made critical historical and doctrinal material widely accessible to church members, often without the scholarly context that specialists say is essential for accurate interpretation.

Why it matters — As online access to critical historical and doctrinal material grows, conferences like FAIR serve as a public arena where Latter-day Saints can watch scholars model how to engage hard questions without abandoning faith or ignoring evidence.

⚠ Not yet confirmed

  • specific dates August 5–7
  • Thanksgiving Point location detail
  • atmospheric details of attendees laughing and leaning in
  • reference to independent scholars
  • shortened Susa Young quote

Reported by deseret.com, fairlatterdaysaints.org

People in this story
  • Brigham Young
    American religious leader, second president of the LDS Church, and governor of Utah Territory (1801–1877)
  • Jesus Christ
    central figure of Christianity (c. 6 or 4 BC – AD 30 or 33)
  • Joseph Smith
    American religious leader and founder of the Latter Day Saint movement (1805–1844)

Community

Be the first to comment.

Share this story
Text Email