Papalocal
Loading…
← All news
Community

How Scholars Proved Spain's Red Terror Was Organized, Not Anarchic

For decades, Republican violence during the Spanish Civil War was blamed on 'uncontrollables.' Archival research has dismantled that myth — and reshaped how Spain understands its own past.

How does this story make you feel?

Source: en.wikipedia.org

For most of the twentieth century, a convenient story held in Spain: the tens of thousands of executions, church burnings, and torture sessions carried out in Republican-controlled territory during the 1936–1939 Civil War were the work of anarchist 'uncontrollables' — fringe elements acting without orders, impossible to rein in. It was a narrative that let the Republican cause keep its moral distance from its own atrocities. Detailed archival research has now collapsed that story.

Work by European History lecturer Dr. Julius Ruiz has changed national consciousness in Spain by demonstrating that Republican extrajudicial terror was not spontaneous mob violence but was organised by revolutionary tribunals. His findings, published in the Spanish-language book El terror rojo, drew on neglected Republican and Francoist documentation to build a case that overturned decades of received wisdom. An English-language version is published by Cambridge University Press.

El terror rojo demolishes the comforting thesis that, unlike the rightist repression which was planned and organised from above, the leftist repression was the work of 'uncontrollables.'— Juan Avilés, historian, writing in El Mundo

The myth Ruiz targeted was specific and politically useful. If Republican killings were the work of rogue actors, the organized Republican leadership bore no institutional responsibility. Ruiz's database of 4,500 policemen who carried out rear-guard duties in Madrid during the war told a different story: the killers were skilled and well educated, with few unskilled workers or peasants, and were later incorporated wholesale into the new Republican police force. Those who did not get jobs in that force became convenient scapegoats — labeled 'uncontrollable' after the fact.

One of the most striking individual cases Ruiz examined was Agapito García Atadell, long held up as the archetype of the uncontrollable anarchist killer. Ruiz showed he was actually a prominent Socialist figure who enjoyed widespread support within the Republican party leadership for his role in eliminating suspected Francoist sympathizers in Madrid.

The scale of what Ruiz was re-examining is not in dispute. The Red Terror — the name historians give to violence committed by leftist factions from 1936 through the war's end — involved the killing of tens of thousands of people, including 6,832 Roman Catholic clergy, alongside attacks on the nobility, business owners, conservative politicians, and suspected rightist sympathizers. Monasteries, convents, schools, and churches were desecrated and burned. No Republican-controlled region escaped the violence entirely, though it was minimal in the Basque Country.

The myth of spontaneity was partly sustained by a second, related myth: that Republican terror was essentially reactive — an understandable if regrettable response to the failed rightist military coup of July 1936. Analysts such as Helen Graham have argued that the coup 'killed off the possibility of other forms of peaceful political evolution,' effectively licensing the violence that followed. But other historians have documented systematic anticlerical violence and political persecution well before the coup — including arson attacks against Church property in May 1931 and the killing of 37 priests and religious students during the Asturian miners' revolt of October 1934.

A third myth concerns who the violence targeted. The Red Terror is often remembered primarily as anticlerical — and the clerical toll was staggering — but historian Julius Ruiz also documented how the Stalinist Communist Party of Spain turned the terror inward, declaring the anti-Stalinist POUM (Workers' Party of Marxist Unification) illegal and unleashing mass arrests, torture, and executions against fellow Republicans, aided by the Soviet NKVD and GRU. George Orwell, who fought with the POUM, documented this purge in Homage to Catalonia; his later novels Animal Farm and Nineteen Eighty-Four were shaped by what he witnessed.

The reception of Ruiz's work in Spain illustrated how charged the subject remains. 2,000 copies of El terror rojo sold in its first month after publication in 2012, prompting a reprint, and the book won Spain's Hislibris Prize for best history book of the year — voted on by readers of the country's largest history-blogging community. Coverage spanned the political spectrum, from left-leaning Radio Nacional to conservative outlets like ABC and La Razón.

The Catholic Church has pursued its own form of reckoning. The Holy See has beatified hundreds of victims of the Red Terror in recent years — 498 in a single 2007 ceremony, the largest single beatification in the Church's history.

What the historical record now shows, across multiple sources, is a violence that was neither purely spontaneous nor purely reactive. It grew from deep structural tensions in the Second Spanish Republic — a government that banned public religious expression, imposed secular schooling by legislative decree, and denied political representation to opponents out of fear of fascism. Historian Stanley G. Payne concluded that the Republic's hostile approach to the Church was 'a substantial cause of the breakdown of democracy and in the onset of the civil war.' The 'uncontrollables' myth, it turns out, was one more casualty of that breakdown.

Why it matters — How a society assigns responsibility for mass atrocities shapes its politics for generations — Spain's reckoning with the Red Terror's organized nature, rather than blaming nameless 'uncontrollables,' is still unfolding.

⚠ Not yet confirmed

  • The upper-end estimate of 110,965 deaths attributed to the Red Terror.

Sources differ on Total deaths attributable to the Red Terror: 38,000 (kids.kiddle.co (citing Antony Beevor)) vs ~50,000 (kids.kiddle.co (citing Paul Preston)) vs 55,000 (kids.kiddle.co (citing Hugh Thomas and Paul Preston)) vs 72,344 (bootcampmilitaryfitnessinstitute.com (citing Julio de la Cueva)) vs 110,965 (wikipedia.org)

Sources differ on Who ordered the 1936 Madrid prisoner massacre: Ordered by a Popular Front revolutionary tribunal, not Santiago Carrillo (hca.ed.ac.uk (Julius Ruiz)) vs Long attributed to Santiago Carrillo, future Communist Party leader (hca.ed.ac.uk (prior orthodox view))

Reported by wikipedia.org, bootcampmilitaryfitnessinstitute.com, hca.ed.ac.uk, blog.acton.org, kids.kiddle.co, victimsofcommunism.org

People in this story

Community

Be the first to comment.

Share this story
Text Email