The historian who rewrote Spain's Civil War memory — one archive at a time
Dr Julius Ruiz's research demolished the decades-old myth that Republican mass killings were spontaneous anarchist violence, proving they were organised from above — and Spain is still reckoning with it.
Source: hca.ed.ac.uk
For decades, a convenient story held in Spain: the tens of thousands killed in Republican-controlled territory during the Civil War were the work of anarchist 'uncontrollables' — hot-blooded radicals acting without sanction from the left's legitimate leadership. It was a story that absolved institutions, protected reputations, and let a fractured country move on. A historian at the University of Edinburgh has spent years dismantling it.
According to the University of Edinburgh's School of History, Classics & Archaeology, Dr Julius Ruiz — a lecturer in European History — has fundamentally shifted the terms of public debate in Spain by demonstrating that Republican extrajudicial terror during the 1936–1939 Civil War was not spontaneous violence but organised killing, carried out by revolutionary tribunals with the knowledge and support of the Popular Front's leadership.
The stakes of that finding are not merely academic. Approximately 50,000 people died in extrajudicial killings in Republican-controlled zones during the war, according to ac.uk. Madrid alone saw more than 8,000 such executions, including the massacre of around 2,400 prisoners in late 1936. For generations, those deaths were framed as the essentially unplanned byproduct of revolutionary chaos — a moral counterweight to the Nationalist atrocities that were, everyone agreed, planned from the top.
Ruiz's research, built on neglected Republican and Francoist archives, collapses that distinction. His database of 4,500 policemen who carried out rear-guard duties in Madrid during the war revealed that the killers were not the desperate underclass of revolutionary mythology — they were skilled, educated men who were later absorbed wholesale into the new Republican police force, according to ac.uk. Those who didn't get jobs in that force, Ruiz found, became the convenient scapegoats labelled 'uncontrollable.'
The accountability question runs deeper still. Ruiz challenged the long-standing attribution of the 1936 prisoner massacre to Santiago Carrillo — the future Communist Party leader whose name had become synonymous with the killings in popular memory. The massacre, Ruiz argues, was ordered not by Carrillo personally but by a Popular Front revolutionary tribunal, according to ac.uk. The distinction matters: it shifts responsibility from one man to a functioning political institution.
He made a similar move with Agapito García Atadell, one of the most notorious figures branded an 'uncontrollable.' Ruiz showed that García Atadell was in fact a prominent Socialist who enjoyed active support from the Republican party leadership for his campaign against the supposed fascist 'Fifth Column' operating inside Madrid, according to ac.uk. The 'uncontrollable' label, in other words, was retrospective cover — applied after the fact to men who had been doing exactly what the leadership wanted.
The appearance of Julius Ruiz's well-conceived and documented study is to be celebrated... because El terror rojo demolishes the comforting thesis that, unlike the rightist repression which was planned and organised from above, the leftist repression was the work of 'uncontrollables.'— Juan Avilés, Historian
That review ran in El Mundo, Spain's second-largest daily newspaper — a signal of how far Ruiz's arguments had travelled beyond the seminar room. When El terror rojo was published in 2012, 2,000 copies sold in the first month, triggering a reprint. Coverage followed on Telemadrid, Radio Nacional, Radio OndaCero, and in ABC, La Razón, La Gaceta, and regional papers across the country, according to ac.uk. In April 2013 it was reissued as a paperback; a month later it won Spain's Hislibris Prize for best history book, awarded by the country's largest community of history bloggers.
The reach matters because the Spanish Civil War remains one of the most politically charged subjects in the country's public life. The conflict — which pitted a left-leaning Popular Front government against a Nationalist rebellion backed by Nazi Germany and Fascist Italy, ultimately won by General Francisco Franco in 1939 — left wounds that outlasted the dictatorship itself, according to Wikipedia. Broader historical estimates put civilian deaths in the Nationalist zone higher than those in the Republican zone, a context Ruiz's work does not dispute. His argument is not that Republican violence was worse, but that it was not what its defenders claimed.
An English-language version of El terror rojo is published by Cambridge University Press, and Ruiz contributed a chapter — 'Fighting the Fifth Column: The Terror in Republican Madrid during the Spanish Civil War' — to the Cambridge volume The Civilianization of War, published online in 2018, according to cambridge.org. The research has thus moved in both directions: into Spanish national consciousness through popular media, and into international academic literature through peer-reviewed channels.
The broader historiography of the Spanish Civil War has long grappled with asymmetric accountability. Nationalist repression — organised purges in captured territory to consolidate Franco's power — has been extensively documented. Republican violence, partly because the Republic lost and its defenders had reason to minimise it, received less systematic scrutiny for decades. Ruiz's archival work represents a generation of scholarship that has tried to apply the same evidentiary standards to both sides.
Why it matters — How a society assigns responsibility for wartime atrocities shapes its politics for generations — Ruiz's archival work shows that the Republican left's official story about its own violence was, at least in part, a constructed alibi.
⚠ Not yet confirmed
- The 1936 prisoner massacre was ordered by a Popular Front revolutionary tribunal rather than by Santiago Carrillo personally
Sources differ on Total civilian deaths in Republican zone during the Spanish Civil War: ~50,000 (ac.uk) vs 38,000–110,965 (en.wikipedia.org)
Reported by ac.uk, cambridge.org, en.wikipedia.org
- Francisco FrancoSpanish general and dictator (1892–1975)
- Santiago CarrilloSpanish politician (1915–2012)