Diesel Hits $6.40 Record as Isolated 'Out of Fuel' Signs Spread Online
Viral photos of empty diesel pumps in Texas and Florida are outpacing the reality — but the underlying supply crunch squeezing prices to record highs is very real.
Diesel hit a fresh national record of $6.40 a gallon on Thursday — up 73 percent from a year ago — as photos of 'out of diesel' signs at stations in North Texas and Orlando, Florida circulated widely on social media. Industry analysts say the outage images are real but isolated, and warn that the panic they are generating could prove more dangerous than the underlying shortage.
Patrick De Haan, head of petroleum analysis at GasBuddy, said his company's nationwide tracking data and its Pay with GasBuddy card network show no broad crisis. Calling those who spread the viral posts "false alarmists," he told Newsweek that social-media outage reports deserve only a "grain of salt" because there is "lots of misinformation that is being misinterpreted or elevated." Temporary shortfalls at individual stations, he added, can stem from unusually high local demand or delivery delays.
Volatility may lead stations to wait a day or three before buying gasoline, but people misinterpret it immediately because we're in very sensitive times. This is a time to fact check everything to avoid runaway panic.— Patrick De Haan, Head of Petroleum Analysis, GasBuddy
OilPrice.com flagged a specific risk in that panic: people rushing to fill up overnight to beat a feared price spike could create the very shortages they are worried about — a self-fulfilling prophecy. EIA figures support De Haan's view on gasoline, showing that inventories climbed 800,000 barrels last week to reach 207.7 million barrels, output rose to 9.6 million barrels per day, and demand trails last year's pace by 1 percent. Crude inventories are 1 percent above their five-year average.
Diesel is a different story. Distillate stocks did rise 1.6 million barrels last week but remain 13 percent below their five-year average, according to EIA data cited by OilPrice.com. In its September outlook, the EIA forecast that distillate fuel oil inventories would slip under 100 million barrels in September and stay beneath the five-year low for much of 2027.
Two simultaneous disruptions are driving the diesel squeeze. The U.S.-Israel war against Iran, launched on February 28, has sharply curtailed traffic through the Strait of Hormuz — the chokepoint through which roughly one-fifth of global petroleum consumption normally passes. Reuters reported that only a single ship exited the strait on Wednesday, identified as an oil tanker using a so-called dark route, compared with 12 vessels the previous day. Separately, Ukrainian drone strikes have damaged Russian refineries on multiple occasions, and Moscow has restricted fuel exports to protect its domestic market. According to Reuters, combined disruptions in Russia and the Gulf have pulled roughly 1.6 million barrels per day of diesel exports off the global market since February.
The price surge is uneven across the country. AAA data as of September 17 show California leading all states with a diesel average of $8.3496 per gallon, with Washington at $7.3640 and Hawaii at $7.0902 rounding out the top three. At the other end of the scale, Oklahoma posted the nation's lowest average at $5.9386, with Texas at $5.9604 and Louisiana at $5.9884 close behind. De Haan pointed to refinery troubles particular to the Great Lakes region as the reason retail diesel has climbed to roughly $6.65 in Michigan, $6.53 in Ohio, $6.49 in Indiana and $6.46 in Illinois; he added that Michigan and several of its neighbors are nearing $7 — a localized refining crisis compounding an already strained global picture.
New Jersey and Maine broke their diesel-cost records Thursday morning, De Haan said, making it 44 states where diesel prices are at all-time highs. On Tuesday, he noted that the six states still short of that threshold — Connecticut, Massachusetts, New Hampshire, New York, Rhode Island and Vermont — each needed only 25 cents per gallon or less to surpass their own records.
The stakes extend well beyond the pump. Trucks, trains and boats that run on diesel move the bulk of consumer goods across the country. The Chicago-based Independent Grocers Alliance has found that fuel-related costs can make up as much as 30 percent of the total cost of some food items, and that a sustained fuel-price increase of 10 to 15 percent can lift retail food prices by 2 to 4 percent. Bureau of Labor Statistics figures show that, as of last month, the price of groceries consumed at home had already risen 2.2 percent compared with the same period a year ago.
The surge has opened a policy debate in Washington. Senate Majority Leader John Thune said he is open to exploring a diesel export ban to keep more U.S.-produced fuel at home.
It is a commodity now that I think we're exporting, and if we need more supplies in this country, and if that would take pressure off of prices, I'm open to exploring it.— John Thune, Senate Majority Leader
Interior Secretary Doug Burgum expressed skepticism, warning that other countries could retaliate by restricting fuel supplies to U.S. markets that rely on imports.
We would consider an export ban if we thought that actually might lower prices, but that's not the case.— Doug Burgum, Interior Secretary
At a North Carolina appearance Wednesday, President Trump conceded that fuel prices were "a little higher" while arguing the cost was justified by his ongoing war against Iran, now in its seventh month; he forecast that prices would "come tumbling down...like a rocket ship in reverse." Former Rep. Marjorie Taylor Greene, posting a video from a California station where diesel was selling for $8.50 a gallon, broke with the president directly: "This is Trump's fault. This should not be this high. It needs to end. Ridiculous."
The EIA's baseline projection calls for crude prices to ease gradually to an average of roughly $74 per barrel in 2027, compared with $91 today, though that forecast depends on conditions stabilizing. With WTI above $100 and the Strait of Hormuz still severely disrupted, analysts see little near-term relief. Gulf Oil chief energy adviser Tom Kloza predicted "staggering increases at the pump for both gasoline and diesel," with the Great Lakes and Rocky Mountain states facing the steepest near-term jumps.
Why it matters — Diesel powers the trucks, trains and boats that move most consumer goods — sustained price records at the pump translate directly into higher grocery bills and broader inflation for every household.
⚠ Not yet confirmed
- SoFi chief market strategist Liz Thomas predicted diesel could rise to $6.65 per gallon by election day, and said trends have since worsened.
- Recent drone attacks against a crucial East-West oil pipeline in Saudi Arabia led to its temporary shutdown, threatening 4% of the world's oil supply.
- Marjorie Taylor Greene posted a video from a California station showing diesel at $8.50 per gallon.
Sources differ on National average diesel price as of mid-September: $6.285/gal (September 14, EIA) (newsweek.com) vs $6.40/gal (Thursday, AAA) (independent.co.uk)
Reported by newsweek.com, independent.co.uk, oilprice.com
- Donald TrumpPresident of the United States (2017–2021; since 2025)
- John ThuneAmerican politician (born 1961)
- Marjorie Taylor GreeneAmerican politician
- Doug BurgumUnited States Secretary of the Interior