LHC experiments find no microscopic black holes — and that absence is itself a discovery
Two CERN detector teams searched billions of collisions for exotic mini black holes and found nothing — results that rule out whole classes of extra-dimension theories and set the tightest mass limits yet.
Two of the world's most sensitive particle detectors have now combed through more than ten quadrillion proton collisions looking for microscopic black holes — and come up empty. That absence, physicists say, is exactly the point.
It's not a dead-end. The result is an exclusion limit, which is a real, publishable statement: 'If this thing existed with these properties, we'd have seen it. We didn't, so we can rule it out here.'— Danyi Zhang, University of California, Santa Barbara
The CMS experiment at CERN analyzed 138 inverse femtobarns of proton-proton collision data collected from 2016 through 2018, when the Large Hadron Collider was smashing protons together at a center-of-mass energy of 13 TeV. No statistically significant excess of events consistent with microscopic black holes — or with a related exotic phenomenon called sphalerons — appeared above the expected background of ordinary particle physics processes. The result excludes such black holes with masses below roughly 9.0 to 11.4 TeV, depending on the theoretical model assumed, extending the reach of previous searches by approximately 1 to 1.6 TeV, according to thebrighterside.news.
Separately, the ATLAS experiment performed its most sensitive search yet using 164 inverse femtobarns of Run 3 data recorded from 2022 to 2024 at a slightly higher collision energy of 13.6 TeV. ATLAS found no significant excess either, and set 95% confidence-level upper limits excluding quantum black hole models with threshold masses up to 9.4 TeV — described by the ATLAS collaboration as the world's best limits to date. The modest energy increase from Run 2 to Run 3 boosted the expected signal rate for the heaviest black holes considered by up to an order of magnitude, according to atlas.cern, making the null result all the more constraining.
Under ordinary four-dimensional physics, the LHC cannot produce black holes. Compressing 13 TeV of collision energy into a black hole would require confining it within a region roughly 10⁻⁵⁰ meters across — far smaller than the Planck length of about 10⁻³⁵ meters, which marks the scale where quantum gravity is expected to become relevant. The searches are motivated by theories proposing that space contains extra spatial dimensions beyond the familiar three. In such models, gravity could spread into those hidden dimensions, making it appear far weaker than the other fundamental forces at everyday scales — a long-standing puzzle known as the hierarchy problem. At extremely short distances, gravity in these models would become much stronger, and the effective Schwarzschild radius for a 13-TeV collision could reach roughly 10⁻²⁰ meters, potentially bringing microscopic black holes within the LHC's reach, according to sciencenewstoday.org.
Such objects would be nothing like the black holes formed by collapsing stars. A microscopic black hole produced in a collider would decay almost instantly through Hawking radiation, releasing a burst of energetic particles — jets, electrons, muons, photons and missing momentum — spreading outward in many directions. That near-spherical spray of particles is the signature physicists searched for. The challenge is that ordinary Standard Model collisions can occasionally produce complicated, energetic events that look superficially similar, so separating a rare signal from that background requires examining many properties of each collision simultaneously.
To do that, the CMS team developed a new technique built around a concept called phase-space distance. Rather than measuring a handful of individual variables, the method represents each collision event as a point in a high-dimensional mathematical space that encodes the momenta and energies of all the particles produced. Two collisions that look physically similar sit close together in that space; events with different structures sit farther apart. A machine-learning algorithm called a support vector machine was then trained to draw a boundary between signal-like and background-like events based on those geometric distances, according to cms.cern and sciencenewstoday.org.
We use a machine-learning framework called support vector machine to teach the analysis to draw a boundary between signal and background that the human eye could never see.— Danyi Zhang and Tamas Almos Vami, University of California, Santa Barbara
The researchers found that phase-space distance outperformed sphericity — a simpler measure of how evenly particles spread through the detector — as a way of distinguishing potential signals from background, according to thebrighterside.news. After applying a signal-score threshold of 0.63 and examining the remaining events as a function of total transverse energy, no excess emerged.
The CMS analysis also searched for electroweak sphalerons — unstable energy configurations in the electroweak field that could, in theory, produce matter without producing antimatter, violating a conservation law that holds in all known natural processes. Sphaleron transitions are of particular theoretical interest because they represent one possible mechanism for the matter-antimatter asymmetry of the universe. The final states expected from sphaleron transitions resemble those from microscopic black hole decay, allowing the same analytical framework to cover both searches. No evidence for sphalerons was found either, according to sciencenewstoday.org and cms.cern.
For the ATLAS quantum black hole search, researchers looked specifically for a decay mode producing a lepton-quark pair: a high-energy electron or muon recoiling against a jet of hadrons, with the combined mass of the pair in the multi-TeV range. The electron-plus-jet channel achieved nearly three times the sensitivity of the muon-plus-jet channel because of its superior momentum resolution at high energies. The highest-mass events recorded reached 5.3 TeV in the electron channel and 5.5 TeV in the muon channel, according to atlas.cern — striking events, but consistent with Standard Model expectations.
Taken together, the two sets of results significantly narrow the parameter space where extra-dimensional theories could still produce microscopic black holes at the LHC. For many scenarios, the presence of more than two extra spatial dimensions is now ruled out at the 95% confidence level, according to cms.cern. The constraints apply specifically to the theoretical models tested, and searches will continue as Run 3 data accumulates and the High-Luminosity LHC eventually delivers far larger datasets.
The consistent shape of the total transverse momentum distribution for backgrounds, as well as how uniformly the final state particles are spread in space, allows us to effectively distinguish between potential signals and background.— Celia Lo, PhD student, University of California, Los Angeles
The LHC is currently in its third long shutdown, during which CERN is replacing the collider's inner triplet magnets — groups of three quadrupole magnets that focus particle beams just before they collide — as part of the High-Luminosity LHC upgrade. The new magnets use niobium-tin superconducting coils capable of generating magnetic fields of 11.3 tesla, about 40% stronger than the current niobium-titanium magnets. That will allow beams to be squeezed more tightly, increasing the collision rate — known as luminosity — for the ATLAS and CMS experiments. The first of the new quadrupoles is expected to arrive in the tunnel at the start of 2029, according to sciencedaily.com. The upgrade sets the stage for the next generation of searches, including deeper hunts for the exotic phenomena that current data have so far failed to reveal.
Why it matters — The results set the tightest constraints yet on theories proposing extra spatial dimensions, and demonstrate that machine-learning tools can extract physics from collision data that conventional methods would miss — a capability that will matter even more as the High-Luminosity LHC generates far larger datasets.
⚠ Not yet confirmed
- The energy increase from 13 TeV to 13.6 TeV boosted the expected signal rate for the heaviest quantum black holes considered by up to an order of magnitude.
Reported by sciencedaily.com, cms.cern, sciencenewstoday.org, thebrighterside.news, atlas.cern
- Stephen HawkingBritish theoretical physicist, cosmologist and author (1942–2018)