Goldman: Diesel Export Ban Would Cut Pump Prices Briefly, Then Drive Gasoline Higher
A White House-floated ban on U.S. diesel exports could shave 25 cents a gallon off diesel costs short-term — but once storage fills, Goldman Sachs warns gasoline prices could climb 30 cents a gallon per week.
The Trump administration is weighing a ban on U.S. diesel exports as a pressure valve on record pump prices — but Goldman Sachs is warning that the relief would be brief and the blowback could hit American drivers at the gasoline pump instead.
Diesel reached a record high of roughly $6.52–$6.53 a gallon on Sept. 22, AAA data show, and had slipped only marginally to $6.45 by the following Monday. The fuel's price has surged 74% since Feb. 27 — the eve of the Iran war — outstripping the 50% run-up in retail gasoline over the same period, according to AAA figures compiled by Bloomberg. Freight railroads and commercial vehicles run on diesel, meaning elevated prices for that fuel send costs cascading through the wider U.S. economy.
President Trump told reporters on Sept. 22 that his administration is 'very seriously' considering a ban on diesel exports. A White House official told CBS News that Trump is evaluating all available options for lowering fuel prices, but that no policy decisions have yet been made.
Trump has said he has called for not sending out diesel, noting that the U.S. makes a lot of it, and that such a step could have some effect on gasoline prices because of the production balance.
The logic behind an export ban has attracted support mainly from Republican lawmakers: U.S. refiners produce more diesel than the domestic market uses, leaving net exports running at roughly 1.5 million barrels a day, S&P Global Energy figures show. Halting those exports, supporters argue, would flood domestic supply and push prices down for farmers, truckers, and other diesel-dependent businesses.
Goldman Sachs estimates that a ban could cut diesel prices by about 25 cents a gallon while refiners still have storage space to absorb the excess. But that window closes fast. Once storage reaches capacity, Goldman projects each additional week of a ban in place could push gasoline prices up by 30 cents per gallon, according to CBS News.
The longer a diesel export ban lasts, the more disruptive it would likely be by putting upward pressure on gasoline prices because diesel, gasoline and jet fuel are largely produced together. Therefore, downward pressure on diesel production can mean downward pressure on gasoline production, i.e. upward price pressure on gasoline.— Goldman Sachs analysts
Goldman's Daan Struyven, co-head of global commodities research, spelled out the mechanism in a Sept. 23 Bloomberg Television interview: lower diesel prices would give refiners less incentive to produce the fuel, and because gasoline and diesel are produced together, that would reduce gasoline availability as well.
All the things equal, lower diesel prices would incentivize refiners to reduce their production. And because gasoline and diesel are usually produced together as a bundle with some flexibility, it would likely reduce the availability of gasoline.— Daan Struyven, co-head of global commodities research, Goldman Sachs
Struyven also cautioned that the design of any restriction matters enormously — whether it is a full ban or a quota, how long it lasts, and whether it is paired with other measures to keep refiners producing.
These are pretty complicated policies. It's very important to think about, you know, do you do it across products? Do you do a ban or a quota? What's the horizon? Do you combine it with other measures incentivizing refiners to keep producing?— Daan Struyven, co-head of global commodities research, Goldman Sachs
JPMorgan analysts reached a similar conclusion in a Sept. 24 report, warning that if a ban extended beyond 30 days, the economics of refining would begin to crack. 'Refiners can't indefinitely produce excess supply. Because a refinery cannot simply stop producing diesel while keeping gasoline output unchanged, operators would ultimately need to reduce how much crude they run,' the analysts wrote, according to CBS News. At that stage, the analysts added, some of the early price relief would start to unwind — the reverse of what policymakers are seeking.
Energy consultancy Wood Mackenzie framed the risk as an irony built into the policy's own design.
The irony of a U.S. diesel export ban is that it would likely increase costs for American consumers. Cutting crude runs to manage the oversupply would shift the cost burden from diesel to gasoline, meaning a policy designed to bring relief at the diesel pump could end up driving prices higher at the gasoline pump.— Alan Gelder, analyst, Wood Mackenzie
The American Fuel & Petrochemical Manufacturers, the trade group for energy producers, cautioned on Friday that preventing refiners from selling surplus diesel abroad would lead them to reduce overall fuel output, gasoline included, thereby pushing prices upward and making the United States more dependent on imported fuel, according to CBS News.
The debate has exposed divisions inside the administration itself. Interior Secretary Doug Burgum and Energy Secretary Chris Wright have both pushed back against an export ban; Wright, a former energy industry executive, has made the case that the administration's priority is expanding supply rather than restricting overseas sales, according to TTNews. Goldman's Struyven characterized Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent's openness to examining the proposal as 'appropriate'.
Futures markets have already reacted to the export ban speculation: diesel futures came under pressure in the days following Trump's comments, even as the underlying supply picture remained tight.
Why it matters — With diesel prices at record highs and the White House actively weighing an export ban, the Goldman analysis shows that a policy meant to ease costs for truckers and farmers could end up raising gasoline prices for every American driver.
⚠ Not yet confirmed
- Goldman views a ban or quota as plausible but not its base case.
- A ban would raise European wholesale diesel prices by approximately $3 per barrel.
- Trump quote presented as verbatim (combined/paraphrased instead)
- final sentence claiming Goldman sees ban as 'plausible but not base case, according to Reuters'
Reported by bloomberg.com, reuters.com, cbsnews.com, ttnews.com, afpm.org
- Donald TrumpPresident of the United States (2017–2021; since 2025)
- Doug BurgumUnited States Secretary of the Interior
- Scott BessentUnited States Secretary of the Treasury
- Chris WrightUnited States Secretary of Energy (born 1965)