France pays more to borrow than Italy and Greece as debt crisis fears grip Europe
French 10-year bond yields have hit their highest level since 2002, the spread over German debt is back at 2012 crisis levels, and investors are asking whether the eurozone's second-largest economy can repay what it owes.
Through much of the last ten years, investors treated French government debt as nearly as secure as German debt. That confidence has begun to crack, and the deterioration is accelerating.
Investors pushed the yield on 10-year French government bonds to nearly 5% last week, a rate the country had not seen since 2002. The gap between French and German borrowing costs — a measure known as the spread — stretched to around 150 basis points, or 1.5 percentage points, reaching levels not touched since the eurozone debt crisis of 2011–2012. Even more notable: France is now paying higher interest rates to borrow than Italy and Greece, the two nations at the heart of that earlier crisis.
Investors have even coined a new shorthand for the situation. Where the 2011 crisis had its 'PIIGS' — Portugal, Italy, Ireland, Greece and Spain — the new term circulating in markets is 'FROGS': French Oversized Government and Social Security, according to the Sydney Morning Herald.
The root of the problem is structural. The French state consistently spends well beyond what it raises in tax revenue, bridging the gap with borrowed money. This year, that deficit is expected to reach 5.4% of GDP — nearly double the EU's 3% limit. Year after year, those deficits have piled up. According to INSEE, France's national statistics office, French public debt stood at €3.6 trillion in the second quarter of 2026, equivalent to 119% of GDP and up from 115.6% a year earlier. Politico reports that France has gone more than 30 years without a balanced budget.
What has changed is not the existence of the problem but the speed at which markets are repricing it. In a note to clients, Intesa Sanpaolo strategists led by Gian Marco Salcioli contended that the pace of the move is more significant than its magnitude: when yields rise this quickly, investor anxiety shifts from the cost of debt to the possibility of not being repaid at all.
The move tends to transform rate risk into something broader, first and foremost credit risk.— Gian Marco Salcioli, Intesa Sanpaolo strategist
Ebury chief economist Enrique Díaz-Alvarez called it "the largest weekly widening in said spread in seventeen years," according to Euronews.
France does have a plan. Prime Minister Sébastien Lecornu's minority government put forward its 2027 draft budget last Thursday, outlining roughly €54 billion in spending reductions and additional revenue measures. The plan aims to bring the deficit down to 5% of GDP next year from 5.4% in 2026, with approximately two-thirds of the consolidation coming through lower spending and the remaining third through tax increases. Among the specific measures are €6 billion in savings apiece from pensions and healthcare, along with a freeze on government expenditure outside of interest payments and defence.
The problem is France's track record. BNP Paribas economist Stéphane Colliac pointed out that France had fallen short of its budget targets in three out of the four years from 2023 to 2026. With both interest payments and defence costs on the rise, Colliac calculates that the government must identify savings of around 1% of GDP simply to reduce the deficit by 0.4 percentage points. Even under an optimistic scenario, he projects debt climbing to 121% of GDP in 2027 and levelling off only at 124% by 2032.
The political deadlock in Paris remains very much unresolved.— Enrique Díaz-Alvarez, Chief Economist, Ebury
Lecornu holds no majority in parliament. Parliamentary debate on the budget is set to open in the National Assembly on 13 October, with a presidential election scheduled for spring 2027. The draft budget has already drawn waves of street protests from unions, public servants and students. According to Politico, Bank of France Governor Emmanuel Moulin has warned that "everything must be done" to avert a debt crisis before that election.
Supply is adding to the pressure. To cover pandemic-era borrowing coming due, the French Treasury intends to issue €340 billion of debt in 2027, a figure €20 billion higher than this year. The makeup of French debt holders adds another layer of vulnerability: in contrast to Italy, where government bonds are predominantly owned domestically, more than half of French debt sits with foreign investors, who tend to pull out more quickly when conditions worsen, according to Politico. Sumitomo Mitsui DS Asset Management, one of Japan's largest asset managers, disclosed at the weekend that it had offloaded its entire holdings of French debt.
The stress is already crossing borders. ING strategists Michiel Tukker and Benjamin Schroeder noted that spreads on Italian and Greek debt over German Bunds had widened by close to 15 basis points amid the turmoil in France. The euro fell to a 17-month low against the dollar on Monday. Currency analysts at Intesa cautioned that worries over French public finances could drive the euro toward $1.10.
Debt dynamics are no longer deemed only a French problem.— Michiel Tukker and Benjamin Schroeder, ING strategists
The question now turning to the European Central Bank. The ECB does possess a targeted bond-purchase mechanism — the Transmission Protection Instrument — built to address disorderly conditions in sovereign debt markets. But it comes with conditions: a country must be pursuing sound and sustainable fiscal policies before the ECB can deploy it. For France, meeting those conditions would require adjustment measures that analysts describe as near-impossible to deliver ahead of the 2027 elections.
Help would likely require real commitment to stability, through fiscal discipline, reforms or both. Getting that support won't be easy politically.— Christian Schulz, Chief Economist, Allianz Global Investors
ING's global head of macro research, Carsten Brzeski, argued the ECB could pause quantitative tightening and reinvest maturing bonds flexibly to send a positive signal to markets — a step short of full intervention. But with eurozone inflation at 3.8% in September, ECB President Christine Lagarde has kept the door open to further rate hikes, limiting how quickly Frankfurt can pivot to support.
The scale of the potential problem is what makes France different from the PIIGS of 2012. When ECB President Mario Draghi pledged to do 'whatever it takes' that year, it was smaller economies that needed rescuing. France is the eurozone's second-largest economy and the seventh-largest in the world. The European Commission has estimated that, on current policy settings, the cost of servicing France's debt could reach €124 billion in 2030 — 60% more than its defence budget, according to the Sydney Morning Herald.
The immediate risk, analysts say, is not insolvency but political paralysis. If Lecornu cannot secure enough parliamentary support, he could be forced from office. Should no budget be approved, France would once again have to fall back on emergency legislation to keep basic government funding in place — as it did in both 2025 and 2026 — with each successive delay chipping further away at investor confidence.
Reality is catching up with us.— Sébastien Lecornu, Prime Minister of France
Why it matters — France is the eurozone's second-largest economy and the world's seventh-largest: if its borrowing costs keep rising and political gridlock prevents fiscal repair, the stress will spread to European bond markets, the euro, and ultimately to mortgage rates and business lending across the continent.
⚠ Not yet confirmed
- Without change, France's deficit would be headed towards 7% of GDP by the end of the decade.
- The euro could be pushed towards $1.10 by French fiscal concerns.
- Lecornu could fail to secure sufficient parliamentary support and be forced from office.
Sources differ on French-German 10-year bond spread peak: 152 basis points (euronews.com) vs 145 basis points (1.45 percentage points) by Monday morning (politico.eu) vs 136 basis points (spread from start of year to recent levels) (smh.com.au)
Reported by euronews.com, politico.eu, ft.com, smh.com.au
- Christine LagardePresident of the European Central Bank
- Mario DraghiItalian economist, academic, banker and politician; former prime minister of Italy
- Sébastien LecornuPrime Minister of France since 2025
- Frank CostelloItalian-American mobster (1891–1973)