Papalocal
Loading…
News
← All news
Science

Astronomers propose July 22, 1889 as possible night behind Van Gogh's 'The Starry Night'

A South Korean research team says forensic astronomy, shape analysis, and Van Gogh's own letters point to a specific predawn sky — one month later than art history has long assumed.

How does this story make you feel?

Vincent van Gogh / Wikimedia Commons

For more than a century, 'The Starry Night' has been read as a product of Vincent van Gogh's turbulent imagination. A team of South Korean astronomers now argues it is something more precise: a faithful, if exaggerated, record of a specific predawn sky — the one that hung over his asylum in Saint-Rémy-de-Provence, France, on or around July 22, 1889.

The study, published in the journal Scientific Reports, was conducted by Elijah Jeong-hyun Kim, CEO of Seoul-based robotic telescope company SLLAB and a doctoral candidate at Kyung Hee University's School of Space Research, along with colleagues at the same institution. Their central claim: the crescent moon, Venus, and the Hyades star cluster in the constellation Taurus — all visible in the painting — align with the real pre-dawn sky over Saint-Rémy on that date, and only that date satisfies every constraint they tested.

That conclusion puts the painting a full month later than the date art historians have accepted for decades. The conventional June 1889 dating rests on a letter Van Gogh wrote to his brother Theo on about June 18, describing 'a new study of a starry sky,' and on the fact that Van Gogh suffered a severe mental breakdown around July 22 that left him unable to paint for more than a month — suggesting, under the old timeline, that the work had to have been finished before that collapse.

Kim and his team challenge both pillars of that argument. On the astronomical side, they point out that in mid-June 1889 the moon was a waning gibbous — far too full to account for the thin crescent Van Gogh painted. The June sky also could not have placed Venus and the relevant star cluster together in the painter's field of view at the same time.

To an observational astronomer, the cluster of stars in The Starry Night is the Hyades in Taurus. But the moment I read the earlier studies explaining it as Aries, I heard the painting calling to me.— Elijah Jeong-hyun Kim, CEO of SLLAB and doctoral candidate, Kyung Hee University

Earlier astronomical analyses of the painting — by Albert Boime in 1984 and Charles Whitney in 1986 — had reached conflicting conclusions and identified different constellations, leaving the question unresolved for four decades. Kim's team argues those studies made a key error by identifying the central star cluster as Aries rather than the Hyades.

To build their case, the researchers made two field trips to France in 2019 — one in mid-June and one around July 22 — and located the ridge southwest of the asylum from which Van Gogh is believed to have sketched the landscape. They used astronomy software to reconstruct the dawn sky for every day in June and July 1889, then narrowed the field to the three dates on which the moon appeared above Venus and both fit within what they calculated to be Van Gogh's narrow field of view from that vantage point. July 22 was the closest match.

I was standing where Vincent had stood 130 years earlier.— Elijah Jeong-hyun Kim, CEO of SLLAB and doctoral candidate, Kyung Hee University

To move beyond qualitative resemblance, the team applied Procrustes shape analysis — a statistical method that compares the geometric shape of two sets of points after correcting for size, position, and rotation — to the five central stars in the painting and the Hyades cluster. The match was confirmed, and was even closer in a pen drawing Van Gogh made after the painting. They also verified that the sky over Saint-Rémy was likely clear on July 22, based on contemporary weather records.

To bring the question into science, which needs quantitative data, we had to measure the degree of resemblance between the star patterns in the painting and the real sky, using shape geometry and statistics.— Elijah Jeong-hyun Kim, CEO of SLLAB and doctoral candidate, Kyung Hee University

On the historical side, the team cross-analyzed Van Gogh's original French and Dutch letters and contemporary weather records, and noted that some letters mention cicadas — an ecological detail they say points to the hotter conditions of late July rather than June. They propose, based on this analysis, that Van Gogh's July breakdown began later in the month than previously assumed, leaving a window in which he could have observed the July 22 sky.

No two skies are the same. Something always changes. I believe Vincent noticed those changes and put them into the painting.— Elijah Jeong-hyun Kim, CEO of SLLAB and doctoral candidate, Kyung Hee University

The researchers are careful about the limits of their claim. Kim acknowledged that Van Gogh painted in a studio at the asylum from sketches and memory, and that the final work may combine observations from several nights. The village in the painting is imaginary. What the team argues most forcefully is not a single locked-in date, but that the sky is rooted in real observation — that 'The Starry Night' is exaggerated reality rather than pure fantasy.

The painting has been held at the Museum of Modern Art in New York. The Van Gogh Museum in Amsterdam, which was not involved in the research, maintains that Van Gogh painted 'The Starry Night' in June 1889. The Amsterdam museum notes that the work was made on a roll of canvas Van Gogh received in early June, and that on July 2 he sent his brother Theo a drawing based on it — before the July 22 breakdown that left him unable to paint for more than a month.

Van Gogh was not concerned with exact likenesses. The positions of the celestial bodies depicted can therefore not form a reliable basis for dating the work.— Van Gogh Museum spokesperson

Donald Olson, professor emeritus of physics and astronomy at Texas State University, also pushed back, arguing that the positions of Venus and the Hyades cluster in the painting do not match their calculated positions, and that the narrow field of view the team assumed — essential to their argument that the Hyades fills most of the canvas — is inconsistent with the much wider field of view needed to encompass the painting's round hills and cliffs, according to The Guardian.

Jose Luis Aragon, a physicist at the National Autonomous University of Mexico who has studied 'The Starry Night' but was not part of the new research, described it as 'a careful and genuinely interdisciplinary study' that addresses 'a real puzzle' — the moon's phase in mid-June — while stopping short of calling the July date settled.

Still, I would see the July date as an intriguing hypothesis rather than a settled answer.— Jose Luis Aragon, physicist, National Autonomous University of Mexico
What I find most convincing is the broader message: The painting is not pure fantasy. Van Gogh watched the real sky very closely.— Jose Luis Aragon, physicist, National Autonomous University of Mexico

Kim, who has never seen 'The Starry Night' in person at MoMA, said the work is ongoing. The team used the same Procrustes method to propose that the stars in Van Gogh's 1888 painting 'Café Terrace at Night' may be the Summer Triangle, and they say further analysis of Van Gogh's other skies is planned.

I hope this work prompts a renewed, multidisciplinary look at the sequence and working methods of the Saint-Rémy paintings. Our conversation with Van Gogh's other skies is still ongoing. We plan to tell those stories one by one.— Elijah Jeong-hyun Kim, CEO of SLLAB and doctoral candidate, Kyung Hee University
I am confident that July 22 is the better date. I will bet on this date.— Elijah Jeong-hyun Kim, CEO of SLLAB and doctoral candidate, Kyung Hee University

Why it matters — The study reopens a foundational question about one of the world's most recognizable artworks — whether Van Gogh was a careful observer of the real sky or a pure fantasist — with implications for how the painting is dated, interpreted, and understood.

⚠ Not yet confirmed

  • Van Gogh's July breakdown began later in the month than previously assumed, leaving a window in which he could have observed the July 22 sky.
  • The stars in Van Gogh's 1888 painting 'Café Terrace at Night' may be the Summer Triangle.
  • headline presented the July 22 date as definitively established rather than a hypothesis advanced by the research team

Sources differ on Date of 'The Starry Night': June 1889, based on Van Gogh's letter to Theo (~June 18), canvas delivery in early June, and sketch sent July 2 (theguardian.com (Van Gogh Museum position)) vs ~July 22, 1889, based on astronomical matching of the crescent moon, Venus, and Hyades cluster, weather records, and letter analysis (abcnews.com / theguardian.com / iflscience.com (Kim et al. study))

Sources differ on Identity of the central star cluster in the painting: Aries constellation (goodnewsnetwork.org (earlier studies, per Kim)) vs Hyades cluster in Taurus (goodnewsnetwork.org / iflscience.com (Kim et al.))

Sources differ on Whether the positions of Venus and Hyades in the painting match their calculated positions: Yes — the convergence of moon shape, Venus position, Hyades shape, weather, and letters all point to July 22 (iflscience.com (Kim et al.)) vs No — the positions of Venus and the Hyades cluster in the painting do not match their calculated positions (theguardian.com (Donald Olson, Texas State University))

Reported by goodnewsnetwork.org, abcnews.com, space.com, iflscience.com, theguardian.com, nypost.com

People in this story

Community

Be the first to comment.

Share this story
Text Email