Papalocal
Loading…
News
← All news
Faith & Religion

Highland Park Methodist votes 90% to leave UMC — but the denomination says it's not that simple

One of America's largest Methodist congregations cast its ballot to break away, but a lawsuit over property and governance means the split is far from settled.

How does this story make you feel?

Adamtu hpumc / Wikimedia Commons

Highland Park United Methodist Church in Dallas — one of the largest and wealthiest Methodist congregations in the country — voted by a margin of more than nine to one on Monday to leave the United Methodist Church, setting up a prolonged legal and ecclesiastical battle with the denomination that insists a ballot alone cannot end the relationship.

Of 4,775 votes cast over October 25 and 26, 90.35 percent supported severing all ties with the UMC, according to the church council's letter to members. Election Trust, a third-party administrator, supervised the balloting. About one-third of the congregation's roughly 15,000 members participated.

This was not an easy decision, and we know it has not been made lightly. For many of us, it is a painful, difficult and emotional decision. For others, the decision was straightforward.— Highland Park Church Council

The church announced it will begin worshiping this Sunday under the name Highland Park Methodist Church — dropping the word 'United' — and aims to complete all operational changes required by the separation by December 1, 2026.

The regional denominational body, the Horizon Texas Annual Conference, moved quickly to contest the vote's legal weight. In a statement released after the results were announced, the conference said the vote does not, by itself, end the church's relationship with the denomination.

While individuals are free to make their own decisions about their religious affiliation, a congregational vote does not, by itself, sever a local church's relationship with The United Methodist Church. The conference has a responsibility to uphold the covenant we share and continues to ask that Highland Park's governing documents be restored in accordance with United Methodist governance. That has been our request from the beginning.— Horizon Texas Annual Conference

At the center of the dispute is the UMC's trust clause — a centuries-old provision, traced to Methodism's founder John Wesley, which holds that local church property is owned in trust for the denomination. Under that clause, the conference argues it retains ownership of Highland Park's buildings and assets regardless of how members vote. A non-jury civil trial is currently scheduled for October 12, 2027.

The conflict has been building for years. In 2022, Highland Park quietly revised its bylaws to give the congregation more control over its own hiring and governance, removing all references to the UMC and its governing text, the Book of Discipline. Bishop Rubén Saenz Jr. of the Horizon Texas Conference learned of the changes and, after meetings in October, December, and March failed to produce a resolution, filed suit against the church in a Dallas civil court in August. The conference amended the lawsuit on October 15, adding a breach-of-contract count and seeking a permanent injunction and monetary damages.

On the same day the conference amended its suit, Highland Park's church council unanimously adopted a resolution calling for the congregation-wide vote and recommending departure. In a written statement, the council said that "the conference and its bishop have irrevocably broken the bond of trust that once existed between our church and the United Methodist Church."

When we face the reality we're in, we don't see a partner anymore for peace and collaboration.— Rev. Paul Rasmussen, minister in residence and former longtime leader

The departure is notable not only for the church's size but for the nature of the dispute. Disagreements over LGBTQ inclusion drove thousands of conservative congregations out of the UMC between 2019 and 2023 — a wave that swept away at least 40 percent of Methodist congregations in Texas — but Highland Park did not join them. The church had instead staked out a middle position, barring same-sex weddings on its property while permitting its clergy to officiate them elsewhere. According to Baptist News Global, this exit is instead a direct challenge to Methodist 'connectionalism' — the principle that all Methodist churches are accountable to one another through shared denominational structures, including the itinerant clergy system and the trust clause.

The church's leadership has insisted the congregation is not abandoning its Methodist heritage, only its formal denominational ties. The church council declared that "our Methodist identity is grounded in our faith, our Wesleyan theological tradition and the ministry to which God has called us," adding, "None of this will change." The council said it would continue to work through the operational steps of separation and communicate regularly with members.

Not everyone in the congregation's orbit supported the move. More than 40 United Methodist clergy with ties to Highland Park released a letter in the days before the vote asking members to reject the measure, contending that calling a vote at all was premature while legal and church processes remained unresolved. Acknowledging the division, the church council said it honored "the point of view and vote of every member."

The church reports having directed more than $12 million in apportionments to the conference and other Methodist organizations since 2022. Situated on a tree-lined block beside Southern Methodist University, and counting former President George W. Bush among its longtime members, the congregation is the largest United Methodist church in the country by membership. If its departure ultimately succeeds — including on the property question — it could have far-reaching implications for the denomination's control over thousands of other church properties across the country.

Under a temporary UMC policy, congregations could seek a limited release from the trust clause provided they satisfied certain conditions, among them a two-thirds majority vote. That policy has since expired, and the 2024 General Conference removed it from the Book of Discipline entirely, leaving Highland Park without that exit path and making the legal contest over its assets the central unresolved question.

Why it matters — If Highland Park's departure succeeds on the property question, it could set a precedent that weakens the UMC's trust clause and its ability to retain assets when other large congregations seek to leave.

⚠ Not yet confirmed

  • Bishop Saenz said on a video call with conference leaders that the denomination's governing text 'does not authorize a local church to unilaterally sever its covenantal relationship.'

Sources differ on Whether the congregational vote legally severs Highland Park's relationship with the UMC: The vote reflects the congregation's will and the church is proceeding as Highland Park Methodist Church. (baptistnews.com) vs A congregational vote does not, by itself, sever a local church's relationship with The United Methodist Church. (umnews.org)

Sources differ on Ownership of Highland Park's property and assets: Church leaders say they are confident the properties will continue to serve their mission. (umnews.org) vs The conference argues the trust clause means it retains ownership; lawsuit seeks injunction and monetary damages. (dnyuz.com)

Reported by dnyuz.com, baptistnews.com, umnews.org, dallasnews.com, chron.com

People in this story
  • John Wesley
    British cleric and founder of the Methodist movement (1703-1791)

Community

Be the first to comment.

Share this story
Text Email