DNA closes 52-year-old Utah cold case, linking Ted Bundy to a second 1974 murder
Exactly 52 years after hunters found Melissa Ann Smith's body, Summit County officials announced DNA evidence ties the killing to Ted Bundy — the second Utah cold case resolved through the same forensic chain this year.
Exactly 52 years after hunters found her body in a wooded area near the Summit and Salt Lake county line, 17-year-old Melissa Ann Smith has been given an official answer: Ted Bundy killed her. Utah authorities announced the cold-case closure on Tuesday, October 27, using DNA evidence to formally name the notorious serial killer — dead since 1989 — as her murderer.
This DNA evidence, when considered alongside evidence related to pattern, motive, means and opportunity, establishes that Ted Bundy was responsible for Melissa Ann Smith's murder. The Summit County Attorney's Office has carefully reviewed the evidence and approved the closure of this case. Although Ted Bundy is no longer alive to face prosecution, advances in forensic science and the continued dedication of law enforcement professionals have helped provide answers in a case that has remained unsolved for over 50 years.— Margaret Olson, Summit County Attorney
The resolution traces directly to a separate breakthrough earlier this year. In April, Utah County detectives confirmed through DNA testing that Bundy had killed another 17-year-old girl, Laura Ann Aime, who vanished after leaving a Halloween party on October 31, 1974, and whose body was found by hikers near American Fork Canyon in late November of that year. Bundy had confessed to Aime's murder before his execution, but it was not until this year that bodily fluid extracted from her body was matched to Bundy's known DNA profile held in a Florida database.
That match set the Smith investigation in motion. According to Summit County Attorney Olson, the Utah State Crime Lab concluded on July 14 that the Y-STR DNA profile recovered from Aime's body matched a profile recovered from Smith's body. That finding, combined with reports on pattern, motive, means, and opportunity, was presented to the county attorney's office on October 7, leading to Tuesday's announcement.
Smith's mother had reported her missing on October 18, 1974. Her nude body was found nine days later by hunters. For more than five decades, no suspect was ever officially named, and the case remained open — sustained largely by speculation and the preserved physical evidence that ultimately cracked it.
This case demonstrates the importance of preserving evidence, even when decades have passed. We have the ability to take a look at these cases again and again.— Rosie Rivera, Salt Lake County Sheriff
Rivera added that when a Summit County detective reached out to her agency in June, a Salt Lake detective was able to locate original investigative reports and evidence from 1974 that helped connect the two cases, according to the Spokesman-Review. Salt Lake County Sheriff's Office Detective Ben Pender, described at the news conference as an expert in cold case homicides, said homicide evidence is kept indefinitely for exactly that reason.
The announcement was made on the 52nd anniversary of Smith's body being found — a detail that was not lost on the officials gathered. Summit County Sheriff Kacey Bates opened the news conference by acknowledging Lt. Alan Siddoway, a 42-year law enforcement veteran who had worked the case and died of cancer on October 11, weeks before the closure he had worked toward was announced, according to Deseret News.
After 50 years, we have reached a point that so many have worked for: Today, I'm announcing the closure of the 1974 homicide investigation into the death of Melissa Ann Smith.— Kacey Bates, Summit County Sheriff
Smith's next of kin, who no longer live in Utah, were notified of the breakthrough. A relative contacted by investigators was described as 'very, very gratified' by the resolution but declined to attend the news conference or speak publicly, according to Fox News.
Bundy went on a violent rampage between 1974 and 1978, sexually assaulting and killing at least 30 women across the American West and Florida. He was convicted of three murders — including the 1978 killings of two Florida State University students and the rape and murder of a 12-year-old girl — and was executed in Florida's electric chair in 1989. A vial of his blood drawn at his 1978 arrest was found in Florida in 2011 and entered into the FBI's national DNA database, giving investigators the tool that has since allowed cold cases to be formally closed.
Bundy confessed to a string of killings in his final days, but not all have been confirmed with evidence. Investigators at Tuesday's news conference made clear that closing Smith's case does not end the inquiry into his other possible victims.
It does not close the book on Ted Bundy.— Ben Pender, Salt Lake County Sheriff's Office Detective
Pender pointed specifically to the case of Nancy Wilcox, a 16-year-old who disappeared in October 1974 in Utah. Bundy confessed to her murder, but her body has never been found and investigators said they have not yet reached a definitive conclusion. 'We'll continue to work that case,' Pender said, according to Deseret News.
With every case closure, may we stomp the memory of Ted Bundy out.— Mike Reynolds, Sergeant, Utah County Sheriff's Office
Why it matters — The case shows how preserved forensic evidence — decades old — can still deliver formal accountability for victims' families, and signals that more Bundy-linked cold cases may yet be resolved.
⚠ Not yet confirmed
- Bundy may be responsible for the killing of Nancy Wilcox, who disappeared in October 1974; her body has never been found.
- Bundy is estimated to have killed anywhere between 20 and 100 women.
- specific month/year 'June 2025' for inter-agency contact (sources vary between May and June)
Reported by theguardian.com, foxnews.com, cbsnews.com, deseret.com, pbs.org, spokesman.com, upi.com
- Ted BundyAmerican serial killer (1946–1989)