A mile underground in South Dakota, scientists begin building the world's largest neutrino detector
Construction starts this week on DUNE, a four-detector behemoth in a former gold mine that could explain why matter — and everything in existence — won out over antimatter.
The LZ Dark Matter Experiment / Wikimedia Commons
A mile beneath the Black Hills of South Dakota, engineers are about to start bolting together four detectors the size of five-storey buildings inside caverns excavated from ancient rock. Their quarry: a particle so ghostly that roughly a trillion of them pass through your body every second without touching a thing.
Construction of the Deep Underground Neutrino Experiment — DUNE — is set to begin this week in the former Homestake gold mine in Lead, South Dakota. The project will fill those caverns with 70,000 tonnes of liquid argon chilled to -200°C, held inside detectors built from more than 4,000 tonnes of steel. Assembling them is expected to take nearly three years; filling them with liquid argon, another year after that.
This is a heavy duty engineering operation. It's like building a ship underground.— Prof David Newbold, UK Science and Technology Facilities Council, DUNE spokesperson
Once switched on, the detectors will sit in near-silence until a neutrino strikes an argon atom — producing a flicker of light and a pulse of electric charge. Most of the neutrinos DUNE studies will arrive in an intense beam fired through 800 miles of the Earth's crust and mantle from Fermilab, a particle physics facility near Chicago. Others will arrive from space, carrying information about stellar explosions and the formation of black holes.
The central scientific prize is answering why the universe is made of matter at all. The leading theory of particle physics holds that the Big Bang should have produced equal amounts of matter and its mirror image, antimatter — and that the two should have annihilated each other, leaving nothing. Something tipped the balance. DUNE will search for subtle differences in the behaviour of neutrinos and their antimatter counterparts, antineutrinos, that could explain the imbalance.
It's a super exciting time to be working on this. Neutrinos do not make sense yet and they could open a door to new physics.— Dr Kate Shaw, experimental particle physicist, University of Sussex
Neutrinos are the most abundant matter particles in the universe, outnumbered only by photons. They come in three varieties, each with a slightly different mass, and they switch between varieties as they travel — a process called oscillation. Which variety is lightest and which heaviest remains unknown; the answer could point to fundamental new forces of nature.
It's a very strange behaviour. It's like me throwing you an apple and it turns into a banana.— Dr Kate Shaw, experimental particle physicist, University of Sussex
The mine has a long history with neutrino science. In the 1960s, physicist Ray Davis descended the same shaft and built a detector from a 100,000-gallon tank of dry-cleaning fluid — perchloroethylene — on what is now called the 4850 Level. Shielded from cosmic rays by a mile of rock, it became the first apparatus to detect neutrinos from the sun, recording them as they struck chlorine atoms and converted them to argon. Davis's work, which ran for nearly three decades, earned him a share of the 2002 Nobel Prize in Physics.
The mine closed in 2001 — it had been the largest and deepest gold mine in North America, producing approximately 41 million ounces of gold and 9 million ounces of silver over 125 years. It was converted into a dedicated underground laboratory, the Sanford Underground Research Facility (SURF), with a $70 million pledge from philanthropist T. Denny Sanford in 2006, a land donation from Barrick Gold Corporation, and more than $40 million committed by the State of South Dakota. The facility was formally established in 2007.
DUNE is not the only major experiment now running at SURF. The LUX-ZEPLIN (LZ) detector — which searches for dark matter rather than neutrinos — reported last month what researchers described as a potential first detection of dark matter. Scientists are now working through the data to rule out every alternative explanation before claiming a discovery.
Jaret Heise, director of science at the Sanford Underground Research Facility, noted the need to consider alternative explanations for the signal and said researchers will spend the coming months scrutinizing the data for every possible avenue that might confuse this signal as a more ordinary type of event.
LZ searches for weakly interacting particles, or WIMPs — subatomic candidates for dark matter, the invisible substance that astronomers believe accounts for 85 percent of all matter in the universe. When a WIMP strikes the core of a xenon atom in the detector's liquid xenon, it produces a tiny flash of light. The depth of the mine shields the detector from the constant rain of cosmic rays at the surface that would otherwise swamp such faint signals. Researchers say they will spend the coming months scrutinising the data before drawing conclusions.
For the town of Lead itself — population modest, mining heritage deep — the transformation of the old Homestake workings into a world-class science campus has carried real consequences for local life and identity.
We've gone from mining the Earth to helping scientists explore the universe. We're incredibly proud and lucky that Dune is happening here, and Surf, which has other experiments like LZ. Having world-class science brings new opportunities, new people and new possibilities for our local businesses and especially our young people.— Robin Lucero, city administrator, Lead, South Dakota
The UK is the largest international partner in the US-led DUNE project, contributing core detector components, computing systems to reconstruct particle events, and the graphite target at Fermilab needed to generate the neutrino beam. Hundreds of scientists from dozens of countries are involved across SURF's various experiments.
Earlier this month, the Nobel Prize in Physics was awarded to Belgian researcher Francis Halzen, who used a cubic kilometre of Antarctic ice to detect high-energy neutrinos from deep space — a sign of how central neutrino science has become to fundamental physics. DUNE's proponents say the field is only getting started.
This really is going to be a golden era. There's a lot more of that to come.— Prof David Newbold, UK Science and Technology Facilities Council, DUNE spokesperson
Why it matters — DUNE and LZ together represent the most ambitious simultaneous attempt in history to answer two of science's biggest open questions — why matter exists and what dark matter is — and both are happening right now in the same converted gold mine.
⚠ Not yet confirmed
- The LZ experiment has detected dark matter for the first time.
- verbatim quotation marks around Jaret Heise statements that were close paraphrases rather than exact matches
Reported by theguardian.com, nytimes.com, mprnews.org, sanfordlab.org
- Francis HalzenBelgian-American astrophysicist
- Mike RoundsUnited States Senator from South Dakota