Eagles bench McKee for Joe Milton, their third starting QB of a season spiraling at 2-6
Two days after coach Nick Sirianni said 'Tanner's our guy,' Philadelphia turned to a quarterback who has never made an NFL start and has been with the team less than a month.
On Monday, Nick Sirianni stood in front of reporters and delivered a clear verdict: 'Tanner's our guy. We're not making any changes there.' By Wednesday, the Philadelphia Eagles had made the change anyway, turning to Joe Milton — a quarterback who has never started an NFL game and has been in the building for less than a month — to try to end a six-game losing streak.
Tanner's our guy. We're not making any changes there.— Nick Sirianni, Eagles head coach
Players were informed of the decision during a team meeting Wednesday, according to the Associated Press. Milton will start Sunday against the NFC East-leading New York Giants at Lincoln Financial Field, becoming Philadelphia's third starting quarterback of the season. The Eagles, who began the year 2-0, sit at 2-6 and last in the NFC East.
McKee had taken over in Week 6 after Jalen Hurts was placed on injured reserve with blood clots in his lungs — an injury expected to end Hurts' season. McKee lost all three of his starts, falling to the Carolina Panthers, the Dallas Cowboys, and the Washington Commanders. The Eagles also briefly used Andy Dalton, who was released after throwing an interception on his only pass attempt, in a loss to the Chicago Bears.
Milton, 26, was signed off the Dallas Cowboys' practice squad on Oct. 16 — the day before Hurts went on IR — and was elevated to McKee's backup last week against the Commanders. A 6-foot-5 former Tennessee quarterback selected by the New England Patriots in the sixth round of the 2024 NFL Draft, he was later traded to Dallas in April 2025, where he served as Dak Prescott's backup before losing the No. 2 job to Sam Howell and landing on the practice squad.
His NFL experience is thin: five appearances, no starts. His most extended action came in Week 18 of the 2024 season with New England, when he completed 22 of 29 passes for 241 yards with one passing touchdown and one rushing touchdown against the Buffalo Bills in a game that had no playoff implications. In four appearances with Dallas last season, he completed 15 of 24 passes for 183 yards, one touchdown, and two interceptions, according to Fox News.
The case for Milton rests almost entirely on his arm. Cowboys coach Brian Schottenheimer compared his arm strength to Brett Favre's, according to CBS Sports, though Schottenheimer also flagged concerns about accuracy and touch — the reasons Sam Howell won the Dallas backup job over him. In three Dallas preseason games this past summer, Milton completed 29 of 43 passes for 378 yards, three touchdowns, and no interceptions for a 118.2 passer rating, per CBS Sports. Since 2024, he has averaged 10.2 air yards per attempt, second-most in the NFL among quarterbacks with at least 50 attempts, according to NFL.com citing Next Gen Stats, and both of his career touchdown passes came on throws of 20 or more air yards.
I'm going to say that the upside, I'm not going to say you put him into a box of what he could be, but the arm talent's real. I think we've talked a lot in here about the touch and how he's developed the touch... I think Joe's going to be a terrific player in this league.— Brian Schottenheimer, Cowboys head coach
Sirianni, who has praised Milton's work ethic, framed the quarterback's preparation positively on Wednesday morning — hours before the move was announced to players.
I think he's worked really hard. Him and [quarterbacks coach] Parks [Frazier] have spent a ton of time together, getting him caught up to speed. I know the developmental periods; those always help to be able to run our plays. But he works extremely hard. He is always in the building, doing the extra things. I like his progression.— Nick Sirianni, Eagles head coach
Milton himself was candid about how much of the playbook he has absorbed. Asked Thursday how much he knows, he laughed: 'Shoot, whatever's in this week.'
I was just pretty much going through the plays, going through the week like I was a starter, or like I was playing, and just being ready. And that's what the NFL is about: just being ready when your name is called, and just preparing for those moments.— Joe Milton, Eagles quarterback
McKee, for his part, said he understood the decision and has been helping Milton get up to speed — walking him through reads, footwork, and concepts from offensive coordinator Sean Mannion's system that McKee has had more time to absorb.
He hasn't been here the whole time with training camp and some of those plays, and so just talking to him about different reads, different footwork things that we've had a little more time on task doing here. And so it's been great just communicating with him things that I've seen in the past, things that we've learned from Jalen or that [offensive coordinator] Sean [Mannion] has communicated in the past, or things that we can reiterate to kind of slow his thinking down, so he can just be free and be able to play like the great athlete he is.— Tanner McKee, Eagles quarterback
The matchup is a brutal one for a debut. The Giants' defense has forced a three-and-out on 32.9 percent of drives this season, the best rate in the NFL, according to NFL.com. The Eagles' offense has gone three-and-out on 34.1 percent of drives — the highest rate in the league, and the highest single-season rate since the 2014 Oakland Raiders finished 3-13 at 35.9 percent. During Philadelphia's six-game skid, the team has been outgained by 889 yards, also the worst in the NFL over that stretch.
The Giants enter Sunday at 4-2-1 and leading the NFC East. Kickoff is set for 1 p.m. ET at Lincoln Financial Field.
Why it matters — With Hurts out for the season and the Eagles in a six-game freefall, Milton's debut against the division-leading Giants is effectively a referendum on whether Philadelphia's season is salvageable — and on whether Sirianni's job is secure.
⚠ Not yet confirmed
- The 'biggest loser' of the Milton decision is someone outside the Eagles organization.
Reported by yahoo.com, cbssports.com, foxnews.com, foxsports.com, nfl.com, archysport.com
- Brett FavreAmerican football player (born 1969)