Caitlin Moran: Hope is not a feeling — it's a decision you make every day
In her new book, the journalist and author argues that hope is not passive optimism but an active practice — and that rewilding a garden or donating blood can be as radical as overthrowing a government.
Caitlin Moran was crying three to four times a day. She had a plan: buy a cottage in Wales, grow her own vegetables, install an iron forge for making rakes in case supply chains collapsed, and sit out what felt like the end of civilisation. Then she discovered that remote Welsh farmhouses are expensive, her husband and two daughters were flatly opposed, and the plan would, in her words, 'literally break up the family.' So she stayed put — and went on a quest instead.
The result is How to Be Hopeful, Moran's account of a year spent trying to feel better about the world without leaving it. The book arrives at a moment when, as Moran puts it, cynicism and pessimism have become the default position for many people — and it makes a pointed argument: that hope is not a feeling you wait for, but a decision you make, and then act on.
I think at the moment we think that the only way we can be hopeful is if the world gets better. Once we realise, we flip that and go, no, how I feel hopeful is by doing hopeful.— Caitlin Moran, journalist and author
The book began, Moran has said in interviews, from a place of genuine collapse. It was 2019, the beginning of what she later recognised as menopause — though she did not know it at the time — compounded by what she describes as the relentless overwhelm of a 24/7 news cycle, social media algorithms, and a political moment that felt ungovernable. Her family, she told the Sydney Morning Herald's Morning Edition podcast, thought 'Mummy was having a nervous breakdown.'
It feels like it's an overwhelm constantly. The phone in your pocket, the TV. It's a 24/7 news cycle, and sprinkled on top of that, you've got someone like Donald Trump being the most powerful man in the world, just suddenly saying things like, 'I'm going to buy Greenland'. Like, the human mind finds it very hard to cope with this kind of situation.— Caitlin Moran, journalist and author
Her attempted solution — the Welsh apocalypse bunker — was, she now acknowledges, simply following the logic of the ultra-wealthy. 'I was just following the money because that's what all the billionaire tech bros have done,' she told the Sydney Morning Herald. 'They've all got apocalypse bunkers in Hawaii and New Zealand, and they clearly know something we don't know.' The problem, she discovered, is that apocalypse bunkers are 'incredibly expensive' and available only to millionaire tech entrepreneurs.
Forced back into ordinary life, Moran began a domestic experiment: staying in the same house in north London, in the same neighbourhood, but systematically changing her days. She quit scrolling, switched from national news to local newspapers, rode buses without headphones and listened to strangers, picked up litter around Finsbury Park, donated blood, and tore up her back garden to rewild it — removing the patio and lawn, installing two ponds, and waiting to see what arrived.
Ever since Caitlin Moran decided to 'invite' nature into her back garden in north London, there's been a steady stream of visitors and new residents: butterflies, bees, frogs, newts, woodpeckers, goldfinches.— Caitlin Moran, journalist and author
The wildlife, she says, has had a measurable effect on her mental health — and she connects it directly to brain chemistry. She has ADHD, which she says means permanently lower dopamine levels, driving the familiar cycle of doomscrolling, comfort eating, and other quick hits. A bird feeder, she argues, offers a better alternative.
If you want a hit that's good for you, put a feeder in your garden and every time you see a bird or butterfly go past, you'll get a massive hit. The day I saw a peregrine falcon was better than any ecstasy tablet I've ever taken.— Caitlin Moran, journalist and author
Donating blood, she told the Sydney Morning Herald, works on a similar principle — but adds something gratitude journals cannot: the knowledge that a concrete act of care has reached a stranger. 'As you watch that bag of blood being taken away on a trolley, you know the next person who sees that is someone who is probably dying,' she said. 'You have sent love and compassion for the world to someone you don't know. It's like a letter that you've sent out into the world.'
Moran's definition of hope draws on Nick Cave's formulation — 'Hope is optimism with a broken heart' — and she is careful to distinguish it from simple positivity. Gratitude, she argues, has real limits: if the underlying message you are absorbing is that the world is terrible and unsaveable, no amount of journalling changes that. The shift she describes is from passive appreciation to active engagement — treating hope less like a mood and more like a practice, comparable in its ordinariness to doing laundry.
It's being aware that things are bad and having gone through bad times yourself, but restabilising and going: 'The only way through this is to be hopeful.' It's about putting on your own oxygen mask before you help others. If you're panicking and crushed by how terrible things are, that doesn't help, so hope is the necessary thing.— Caitlin Moran, journalist and author
The political dimension of the argument is one Moran presses hard. Studying history during her quest, she says, revealed a pattern: anxious, despairing populations tend to serve the interests of the powerful. She applies this directly to social media companies that profit from division, and to governments and corporations that benefit when people feel too overwhelmed to demand change.
If you have an anxious, depressed and suppliant populace, it's for the benefit of — and often engineered by — the richest and most powerful people in society: people who want sad, anxious peasants feeling things are hopeless. What you don't want is for people to rebel and go: 'No, I want there to be a better world.'— Caitlin Moran, journalist and author
This is where Moran's personal history becomes relevant. She grew up in poverty in Wolverhampton, one of eight children in a council house, her family surviving on her father's disability benefits. At 15, she pitched a piece to The Times in London to earn money to buy bunk beds for her siblings, who were sleeping on the floor. The Times took it; she has had a column there ever since. The refusal to accept that things cannot improve, she says, came directly from that childhood.
I grew up in a household that palpably wasn't working. My parents were just, like: 'Well, this is just the way things are.' From a very early age, my rebellion was to go: 'I don't accept that things can't get better.'— Caitlin Moran, journalist and author
Her most urgent argument, though, is about children. Young people, she says, are absorbing the despair of the adults around them — hearing dinner-table conversations that conclude the world is irredeemably broken — and drawing the logical conclusion that there is no future worth having.
It's not our right to tell kids: 'Everything's fucked, bad people are in charge of the world, and we can't do anything.' The future is theirs. The one favour we can do our kids is to look them in the eye and tell them: 'You'll find a way through this. You're brilliant. There is hope.'— Caitlin Moran, journalist and author
Moran is candid that her position as a successful, well-paid journalist gives her options most people do not have. But the core proposition of the book — that hope is a practice requiring active cultivation, not a state that arrives when circumstances improve — is one she argues is available regardless of income. You cannot save the world, she concedes. But you can change your street, your garden, your day. And, the book suggests, that is where it starts.
Why it matters — At a moment when anxiety diagnoses are rising across age groups and social media platforms profit from outrage, Moran's argument that despair is partly engineered — and that small, local actions are a form of political resistance — offers a framework that is both personal and structural.
⚠ Not yet confirmed
- Moran spent 30 years 'addicted to her anxiety', which she says was once a driver of her success before it began to destroy her.
- published in 2026
Reported by positive.news, penguin.co.uk, rnz.co.nz, forbes.com, smh.com.au
- Caitlin MoranEnglish author and broadcaster
- Donald TrumpPresident of the United States (2017–2021; since 2025)
- Nick CaveAustralian musician and singer