DA won't charge driver who fell asleep, killing 2 at Wichita youth soccer game
After 100+ interviews, vehicle reenactments and toxicology tests, Sedgwick County's DA says the October crash at Stryker Sports Complex was a civil matter, not a crime.
The woman who drove a Chevrolet pickup truck onto a crowded youth soccer field in Wichita on October 17, killing a 6-year-old boy and a 35-year-old man and injuring ten others, will not face criminal charges. Sedgwick County District Attorney Marc Bennett announced Thursday that a nearly month-long investigation concluded she had fallen asleep in what she believed was a parked vehicle — and that her actions, however catastrophic, did not meet the legal threshold for a crime under Kansas law.
As bad as this was, it is not a crime. This is a civil matter that will be handled under a negligence standard, which is the standard in civil cases. This is not a crime, and I cannot charge this driver with a crime.— Marc Bennett, Sedgwick County District Attorney
The victims were 6-year-old Cole Adrian and 35-year-old Nicholas Schafer, both of McPherson. They were not related, according to KCTV5. The ten injured ranged in age from 5 to 68 years old; Bennett said none were facing critical injuries at the time of the announcement.
Wichita Police Chief Joe Sullivan walked reporters through a detailed timeline. The 34-year-old driver — who has not been publicly identified because no charges were filed — left her Garden City home around 7 a.m. that Saturday, making a trip of more than 200 miles to Wichita's Stryker Sports Complex for her children's soccer matches. She was driving her husband's Chevrolet Silverado, a truck she did not normally use; according to ABC News, her own car had tire issues. The family arrived at the complex by 10:40 a.m., left around 1:20 p.m. for lunch and errands, and returned roughly an hour later to a crowded parking lot.
Surveillance video showed the truck circling the lot for several minutes before finding one of the few remaining stalls — one that happened to sit directly in front of an open pathway onto the fields. Bennett was careful to note that was not by design.
Through a sad coincidence, she finds the one stall that's right there in front with an open pathway onto the fields. No indication whatsoever that she waited for that stall to come open, it's just happenstance.— Marc Bennett, Sedgwick County District Attorney
After pulling in, the woman reclined her seat to a horizontal position and fell asleep. Her 14-year-old daughter then placed a sun shade over the windshield. Surveillance footage showed the truck stationary for 46 minutes before it accelerated over the curb and onto the field. Witnesses told police the woman appeared 'sleepy' and was 'crying hysterically' when she got out of the truck.
The central forensic question was whether the truck had ever been placed in park. Investigators found a telling clue in the Silverado's own design: the truck automatically locks its doors when left in drive. Two of the woman's children told police they had to unlock the doors to exit — consistent with the truck never having been shifted into park. Bennett's report concluded that the truck was most likely left in drive, held in place by a 7-inch parking curb, until the driver inadvertently pressed the accelerator in her sleep.
What we found was that the truck could be parked in that parking spot against that seven-inch curb, and if left in drive, would not go over that curb. It was only when gas was applied ... would those tires overtake the curb.— Joe Sullivan, Wichita Police Chief
To confirm that finding, Wichita police borrowed a truck of the same make, model, and mileage from a local Chevrolet dealership. During a reenactment with automotive technicians, even light pressure on the gas pedal was enough to bring the twin truck over the curb and onto the field. A General Motors engineer and technician who flew to Wichita to examine the actual vehicle found no mechanical defects.
Investigators also ruled out every other explanation. A blood sample the woman voluntarily provided showed no impairing substances, according to testing by the Sedgwick County Regional Forensic Science Center. Her medical records revealed no underlying condition that could have caused a medical episode. The investigation drew on more than 100 interviews, security camera and cellphone footage, toxicology reports, and the vehicle reenactment.
The legal question Bennett then had to answer was whether leaving the truck in drive — what he called a 'single act of inattentiveness' — constituted a conscious disregard of risk, the standard Kansas law requires for charges including first- or second-degree murder, child endangerment, or involuntary manslaughter. He concluded it did not.
Would Chief Sullivan send the cops through the parking lot now, of every soccer game … looking for sleepy parents on Saturday mornings who are taking a nap in their car and go, 'Bud, you're guilty of reckless endangering'? … No, of course not.— Marc Bennett, Sedgwick County District Attorney
Bennett also addressed the possibility of future charges directly, saying 'I think we're done here.' Sullivan said he met with the victims' families earlier Thursday to walk them through the findings before the public announcement.
Our responsibility is to tell you what the evidence shows, what it does not show, and be transparent about the difference. This investigation has been thorough, deliberate, and guided by the facts at every step.— Joe Sullivan, Wichita Police Chief
The crash occurred during a busy day at Stryker Sports Complex. The Kansas State High School Activities Association's inaugural flag football semifinals were taking place on an adjacent field at the time; those games were suspended. The state championship was played four days later, on October 21, according to KCTV5.
Why it matters — The case tests the limits of criminal law when a tragic accident — with two dead and ten injured — stems from a single lapse of attention rather than recklessness or intent, leaving accountability to the civil courts.
⚠ Not yet confirmed
- Investigators do not know whether it was the driver or a child who inadvertently placed the truck into drive, if it had been in park.
Reported by kansas.com, lawrencekstimes.com, kctv5.com, abcnews.com
- Thomas AquinasItalian Dominican friar, philosopher, Catholic priest, and Doctor of the Church (1225–1274)