Arizona Republicans locked out of state power, asking: 'Were we too Maga or not Maga enough?'
Democrats swept every statewide office in Arizona and won a legislative trifecta unseen since 1966, leaving a fractured GOP to fight over whether Trump-era politics or a lack of it caused the collapse.
A decade ago, Republicans held every lever of statewide power in Arizona. Today, they hold none. Democrats swept every statewide office on the November ballot — from governor to mine inspector — and secured a lawmaking trifecta the party had not held since 1966, completing a political reversal that has left Arizona Republicans locked out of state government and at war with each other over who is to blame.
Governor Katie Hobbs, the Democratic incumbent once considered vulnerable, won reelection by more than 10 percentage points over Republican Congressman Andy Biggs, a longtime supporter of the Make America Great Again movement. Democrats also took control of both chambers of the state legislature and sent five Democrats to represent nine of Arizona's congressional districts. At the federal level, Democrats retook both chambers of Congress.
Now, Arizona will have a Democratic trifecta for the first time in 60 years. We're going to need a lot more pizza.— Katie Hobbs, Governor of Arizona
The pizza reference was a dig at the Democrats' own recent past: when the party was so outnumbered in the state legislature, the joke went, its caucus could share a single pizza. That era is now over — and Republicans are left trying to understand how they got here.
The losses were sweeping enough to produce improbable results. A 19-year-old sophomore at Arizona State University defeated a tenured Republican to become the superior county clerk of Maricopa County — the fourth-largest county in America — taking charge of court records, marriage licenses, child support filings and more, according to The Guardian.
Among the most urgent questions now facing the party is a deceptively simple one, posed by Kirk Adams, a former Arizona House speaker who served as chief of staff to the last Republican governor.
Were we too Maga or not Maga enough?— Kirk Adams, former Arizona House Speaker
The question captures the core split inside the Arizona GOP. On one side are those who argue the party was captured by outside hard-right operations — particularly Turning Point Action, the youth-oriented conservative group founded by the late Charlie Kirk and headquartered in Phoenix — and lost touch with the independent voters who make up the largest share of Arizona's electorate. On the other are those who insist the problem was insufficient conservative conviction, pointing to hard-right candidates who survived the blue wave as proof their approach works.
Gina Swoboda, a former chair of the Arizona Republican Party who ran for secretary of state this year, is firmly in the first camp. She lost her own primary to Alexander Kolodin, a Trump ally heavily involved in efforts to overturn the 2020 election results in Arizona. Kolodin was then beaten decisively by Democratic incumbent Adrian Fontes.
I could see this coming. We weren't talking to people, we weren't listening to people.— Gina Swoboda, former chair of the Arizona Republican Party
Swoboda argued that Turning Point Action had effectively played kingmaker in Republican primaries — backing candidates who then failed with the broader electorate — while the official party apparatus was left without comparable resources. She said the group's endorsements backfired: every statewide candidate it backed lost.
We are in the wilderness. Who is going to give money to a party that is run by Turning Point Action?— Gina Swoboda, former chair of the Arizona Republican Party
Turning Point Action is a political organization who has made it its mission, its stated mission, to primary incumbent Republicans that they don't like, that don't meet their definition of what a Republican should be.— Gina Swoboda, former chair of the Arizona Republican Party
The recriminations have drawn in the McCain family. Meghan McCain, daughter of the late Senator John McCain, publicly clashed with Turning Point Action's chief operating officer Tyler Bowyer after he criticized the family's political commentary on social media, calling their takes 'awful' and accusing Meghan McCain of 'playing the Daddy's name fiddle every time a Republican loses.' McCain fired back in a series of posts, arguing that Turning Point had alienated the coalition of independent and moderate voters that her father had long held.
Turning Point doesn't get to disrespect and blame me, my Dad's legacy, independents, moderates, and 'McCain republicans' for Arizonas history making losses and then I'm somehow expected to work with everyone now? They don't value or respect our coalition of voters.— Meghan McCain
My Dad was the last sitting Senator to easily win as a Republican and is still beloved in Arizona. There are lessons from his legacy to be learned and you only further alienate the vital independents by disrespecting him.— Meghan McCain
John McCain died in August 2018. Trump continued to disparage the former senator after his death, and many of Trump's supporters followed. Jack McCain, John's son, briefly made his social media account public to respond to Bowyer's comments before making it private again, according to the Washington Examiner.
Turning Point Action's own leadership urged Republicans to stop pointing fingers. One day after the election, CEO Erika Kirk issued a statement calling internal recrimination counterproductive.
The biggest mistake conservatives can make right now would be to allow this moment to become another exercise in finger-pointing, in-fighting, or trying to secure their own political preservation. That does not solve the problems the American people are demanding be solved.— Erika Kirk, CEO of Turning Point USA
Bowyer, for his part, pushed back on the idea that more moderate candidates would have fared better, and sketched out a tentative 2028 strategy: early agreement on a candidate to challenge Democratic US Senator Mark Kelly, early funding commitments from groups such as the Club for Growth, and a push to turn out voters who don't regularly participate — acknowledging the party may need support beyond its Republican base to win.
FYI, in many places more 'moderate' Republican candidates lost more ground than conservatives. Many examples of this in red states and swing states.— Tyler Bowyer, chief operating officer of Turning Point Action
The structural challenge for Republicans is real. The party holds a nearly 300,000 voter-registration advantage over Democrats in Arizona, but independent voters — the largest share of the electorate — broke hard against Republicans this cycle. And the loss of every statewide office strips the party of the political infrastructure it would normally use to rebuild.
Typically you have a governor or a senator who has a political machinery in place. We don't have that now.— Kirk Adams, former Arizona House Speaker
The world has changed, so if there is no change from the party, we'll be looking at minority status for a long time. Political parties tend to react to near-extinction events like this.— Kirk Adams, former Arizona House Speaker
Arizona's political shift has been building for years, driven by demographic change, a population boom in the Phoenix suburbs, and the growing influence of independent and college-educated voters who have moved away from the Republican Party under Trump. The state was once the home of Barry Goldwater's brand of rock-ribbed conservatism and John McCain's maverick streak. Some Republicans argue the midterm result is an anomaly tied to a difficult national environment and predict a rebound in 2028, a presidential election year. Others say the losses reflect a deeper realignment that cannot be reversed without fundamental change.
Why it matters — Arizona's Republican collapse — in a state the party once dominated entirely — is the clearest test case yet of whether the Trump-era GOP can win back independent voters without fracturing over the very question of how much Trumpism to embrace.
⚠ Not yet confirmed
- Turning Point Action poured millions of dollars into Republican campaigns for governor and Congress in Arizona.
- specific margin of 'roughly 13 percentage points' (source states 'more than 10')
Sources differ on Whether more moderate or more conservative Republican candidates performed better in 2026: Moderate candidates would have fared better; hard-right nominees alienated independents and cost the party statewide. (theguardian.com (Swoboda, Adams)) vs In many places, more moderate Republican candidates actually lost more ground than conservatives did. (theguardian.com (Bowyer, Turning Point Action))
Reported by theguardian.com, movement.vote, azcentral.com, world-today-journal.com, washingtonexaminer.com, reuters.com
- Donald TrumpPresident of the United States (2017–2021; since 2025)
- John McCainAmerican politician (1936–2018)
- Charlie KirkAmerican political activist (1993–2025)
- Barry GoldwaterAmerican politician and military officer (1909–1998)
- Mark KellyAmerican politician, astronaut, and naval officer (born 1964)
- Erika KirkAmerican businesswoman and podcaster (born 1988)