Papalocal
Loading…
Papalocal · Things
Work

Mind or Instinct: An Inquiry Concerning the Manifestation of Mind by the Lower Orders of Animals

Mind or Instinct: An Inquiry Concerning the Manifestation of Mind by the Lower Orders of Animals is a 1843 essay by Lewis H. Morgan.

Released
1843 (1843)
Written by
Lewis H. Morgan
Country of origin
United States
All 5 facts, and where they come from

Facts

5 facts · 0 confirmed by two sources · 0 cited · 5 from one source

What it is
essay One source
Written by
Lewis H. Morgan One source
Released
1843 (1843) One source
Language
English One source
Country of origin
United States One source

Where this comes from

Papalocal keeps its own record. It started from these sources; what each one said is kept here as it was copied, so a change on their side never changes this page by itself. Tap one to read its version.

What Wikidata says · copied November 16, 2026 · revision 2462264030
Described as
1843 essay by Lewis H. Morgan
Other names
Mind or Instinct, an Inquiry Concerning the Manifestation of Mind by the Lower Orders of Animals, Mind or Instinct
What it is
essay
Written by
Lewis H. Morgan
Released
1843 (1843)
Language
English
Country of origin
United States
Wikipedias with a page
1

Wikidata item Q136303873 (wikidata.org/wiki/Q136303873), public domain (CC0). Copied 2026-11-16.

What Wikipedia says · copied November 16, 2026 · revision 1379749842

"Mind or Instinct: An Inquiry Concerning the Manifestation of Mind by the Lower Orders of Animals" is an 1843 essay by American anthropologist Lewis H. Morgan, published under the pseudonym "Aquarius" in The Knickerbocker. Morgan argues that humans and other animals possess the same intellectual principle, differing in the degree to which their mental abilities are developed. Examining animal memory, abstraction, imagination and animal reasoning, he rejects the distinction between human intelligence and animal instinct as an adequate explanation of animal behavior. The essay concludes with reflections on human obligations towards animals, including opposition to cruelty and consideration of vegetarianism.
Later scholars have examined the essay as an early contribution to comparative psychology and as an expression of ideas about human-animal continuity that Morgan developed in subsequent writings.

From the Wikipedia article “Mind or Instinct: An Inquiry Concerning the Manifestation of Mind by the Lower Orders of Animals” (en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mind_or_Instinct:_An_Inquiry_Concerning_the_Manifestation_of_Mind_by_the_Lower_Orders_of_Animals), by its contributors, under CC BY-SA 4.0 (creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/4.0/). Copied 2026-11-16; not changed.

Confirmed Two sources agree. Cited One source, and it names where it got it. One source One source, without a reference of its own. Sources disagree The sources disagree. We show the best-supported value and keep theirs below.

Picture: Lewis H. Morgan, via Wikimedia Commons · Public domain

People connected 1

Known for it