Mediators push amended US-Iran deal as nuclear demands stall Hormuz talks
Qatar-led mediators are shuttling between Washington and Tehran on a revised proposal to reopen the Strait of Hormuz, but deep gaps over nuclear concessions and who moves first are blocking any agreement.
Eight months into a conflict that has pushed Brent crude above $108 a barrel and choked one of the world's most critical shipping lanes, mediators are quietly circulating a revised proposal to reopen the Strait of Hormuz — but the US and Iran remain deadlocked over a single, loaded question: who blinks first.
Three regional officials and two US officials told the Associated Press that behind-the-scenes diplomatic efforts are continuing despite President Trump's public rejection last Saturday of Iran's latest ceasefire offer. Iranian Foreign Minister Abbas Araghchi, who stayed in New York after the UN General Assembly, met with Qatari mediators on Monday and separately with UN Secretary General António Guterres, whose office said he welcomed recent diplomatic efforts and urged both parties to keep talking, according to the Boston Globe.
They want to make a deal to open the Hormuz Strait immediately because they're losing so badly.— President Donald Trump
Iran's proposal, floated by Araghchi on the sidelines of the General Assembly last Thursday, offered to reopen the strait within seven days in exchange for the US lifting its naval blockade of Iranian ports, releasing frozen Iranian assets, and waiving sanctions on Iranian oil sales. Araghchi told reporters the seven-day clock would start "as soon as the United States accepts this plan." At a closed-door UN meeting, he also framed the deal as one that could benefit Trump in the midterm elections, according to the Boston Globe.
The draft text being discussed by mediators would reopen the strait in line with a separate arrangement Iran has been negotiating with Oman, and would include no shipping tolls — a condition Tehran has insisted upon. That Oman framework is designed to temporarily manage traffic on what was treated as an international waterway before the conflict began, according to the Boston Globe.
But the Trump administration has drawn a firm line: no deal without progress on nuclear issues. One US official told the AP that Trump is willing to offer sanctions relief and release some frozen funds in exchange for concrete nuclear steps, including allowing inspectors into the country. While Iran has signaled flexibility on nuclear matters, the two sides are far apart on timing and sequencing — the same fault line that caused a memorandum of understanding signed in June to collapse within days, after Iran fired on commercial ships in the strait.
That breakdown has made Washington deeply skeptical. US officials told the AP they doubt whether Iran can be persuaded to meet Trump's conditions and whether it would honor any commitments it makes. They also said they believe their negotiating position is strengthening as sanctions continue to squeeze Tehran's economy.
Arab officials and mediators told the Wall Street Journal, as reported by the Jerusalem Post, that Iran has not softened its position since Trump rejected the ceasefire offer, and that Tehran wants the US to move first before any further negotiations. One high-level Middle East government official involved in the talks told the WSJ that Iran had come close to compromising on its nuclear program earlier this year during negotiations with Vice President JD Vance, but would need explicit assurance it would not face an Israeli attack after striking a deal with Washington.
Right now, a concession at this time by any party would be considered an expression of weakness by the other and not just a willingness to settle matters.— Umer Karim, Gulf security researcher, University of Birmingham
The economic pressure is real on both sides. The US is absorbing the cost of elevated oil prices driven by Iran's attacks on shipping through the strait, while Iran is contending with a naval blockade and mounting sanctions that have bottled up its oil exports. A senior US official told the AP that Trump remains open to a non-military resolution if one can be achieved, despite his often combative public statements.
The conflict's geography is also expanding. Iran-backed Houthi rebels in Yemen have taken up positions along the Bab el-Mandeb Strait at the southern entrance to the Red Sea — a second critical chokepoint — adding further pressure to global energy markets. Iran has argued that the Houthis operate independently and that their conflict with Saudi Arabia is separate from the US-Iran war, but Iranian officials told the AP they are willing to help broker a settlement between the Houthis and Riyadh.
Iran's supreme leader, Ayatollah Mojtaba Khamenei, issued a rare statement Monday referencing "painful blows" dealt to enemy forces near the strait and warning that "before long, the Arabian Sea, too, will be rid of them," according to the Boston Globe — a signal that Tehran is not projecting weakness even as mediators work the phones.
As of late September 2026, no breakthrough has been reported. The conflict is in its eighth month, multiple prior shipping safety efforts have failed, and the revised proposal remains in draft form with mediators still shuttling between the parties.
Why it matters — A failure to broker a deal keeps one of the world's most critical oil shipping routes closed, sustaining elevated global energy prices and risking further escalation as a second chokepoint — the Bab el-Mandeb — comes under pressure.
⚠ Not yet confirmed
- Iran is confident it could withstand a long-term US blockade or renewed bombing campaign.
- Iran has not compromised at all since Trump rejected the ceasefire offer and wants the US to offer concessions before continuing negotiations.
- Iran believes Trump and the Republican Party will lose the midterm elections, which may increase his willingness to use force against Iran.
- Iran would need explicit assurance it would not be attacked by Israel after making a deal with the US.
Reported by reuters.com, bostonglobe.com, jpost.com, politico.com
- Donald TrumpPresident of the United States (2017–2021; since 2025)
- António GuterresSecretary-General of the United Nations since 2017
- JD VanceVice President of the United States since 2025
- Mojtaba Khamenei3rd Supreme Leader of Iran since 2026
- Abbas AraghchiIranian diplomat, Minister of Foreign Affairs (born 1962)