UC Davis mathematicians say Einstein's equations alone may explain cosmic acceleration — no dark energy needed
A new proof published in Proceedings of the Royal Society A argues the universe's standard expansion model is mathematically unstable, suggesting cosmic acceleration could emerge from Einstein's original gravity equations.
For nearly three decades, dark energy — an invisible, poorly understood force — has been cosmology's best answer to one of its biggest puzzles: why is the universe not just expanding, but accelerating? A team of mathematicians at the University of California, Davis, now says the question may have been answerable all along using Einstein's original equations, no mysterious extra ingredient required.
The study, published in Proceedings of the Royal Society A and authored by Christopher Alexander, Blake Temple and Zeke Vogler, presents a mathematical proof that the standard model of cosmic expansion is inherently unstable — and that this instability could itself drive the acceleration astronomers observe. The finding directly challenges the Lambda-cold dark matter model, the framework scientists have used since the 1990s to describe the universe's evolution since the Big Bang.
Temple, a distinguished professor emeritus of mathematics at UC Davis and the study's corresponding author, reached for a simple image to explain the core claim.
All the forces are in balance when a pencil is standing on end, so it is a 'solution of the equations.' But it's unstable. Any breath of air and it falls away.— Blake Temple, distinguished professor emeritus of mathematics, UC Davis
The standard model, Temple argues, is that pencil. Its mathematical foundation rests on what are called Friedmann spacetimes — models that describe a universe where matter expands but remains evenly distributed throughout space at any given moment. The team's analysis shows these spacetimes are unstable to radial perturbations at large length scales during the matter-dominated epoch of the Big Bang. In physics, an unstable solution is generally considered unphysical: it describes a state that cannot persist in nature.
Unstable solutions in physics and science are considered not physical. You'll never observe them in nature.— Blake Temple, distinguished professor emeritus of mathematics, UC Davis
The researchers used the Einstein-Euler equations — a mathematical framework that combines Einstein's general relativity with the equations governing how fluids behave — to study what happens when the standard model is slightly disturbed. Rather than fading away, those disturbances grow. The team's proof covers Friedmann spacetimes with spherical symmetry and pressureless matter, and Temple says the conclusion holds whether or not a cosmological constant — the mathematical term associated with dark energy — is included.
We prove that, like Einstein's static model, the Friedmann spacetimes are all unstable to radial perturbation at large length scales. This appears to rule out the Lambda-cold dark matter model as a viable stable solution of the Einstein equations of general relativity, with or without dark energy.— Blake Temple, distinguished professor emeritus of mathematics, UC Davis
If the real universe drifts away from the Friedmann model as the math suggests it must, the team argues, the accelerating expansion becomes a natural consequence of Einstein's equations rather than evidence of a separate, unknown energy source.
The instability of all Friedmann spacetimes to accelerated expansion suggests a simpler, more natural explanation for the acceleration of the universe than dark energy.— Blake Temple, distinguished professor emeritus of mathematics, UC Davis
Dark energy entered the cosmological mainstream in the 1990s after two independent teams studying distant Type Ia supernovae found that the universe's expansion was speeding up. Saul Perlmutter, Brian Schmidt and Adam Riess received the 2011 Nobel Prize in Physics for that discovery. The leading explanation became the cosmological constant — a term Einstein himself had introduced in 1915 to produce a static universe, then abandoned after Edwin Hubble's 1929 discovery of cosmic expansion. Einstein reportedly called the constant his 'biggest blunder,' since without it his equations could have predicted expansion. The constant was revived in the 1990s and became closely associated with dark energy in the Lambda-CDM framework.
The UC Davis team did not set out to overturn cosmology. Their starting point was a different question: could a massive shockwave explain the universe's early expansion?
Our first idea was that maybe the universe was expanding because there was a shockwave, and the anomalous acceleration was the expanding wave behind that shockwave. Then we realized there's a family of self-similar solutions during the radiation epoch of the Big Bang, which might model that expanding wave.— Blake Temple, distinguished professor emeritus of mathematics, UC Davis
That line of inquiry led them to self-similar solutions — mathematical patterns that retain their structure across different scales, analogous to a fractal. Building on earlier work, the team used a self-similar form of the Einstein equations to represent the standard cosmological model as a mathematical rest point, then tested whether small departures from that state would shrink or grow. The result was the instability proof at the heart of the new paper.
The mathematics also produces a consequence that cuts against one of cosmology's foundational assumptions. The team's model implies that the Big Bang would look like a standard Friedmann spacetime near a centre of symmetry, but that observers far from that centre would see accelerated expansion. That geometry requires a special location — which collides with the Copernican principle, the long-held idea that Earth does not occupy a privileged position in the universe.
Both the Lambda-cold dark matter model and a spherically symmetric spacetime produce a special place where we must lie for the model to be physically plausible. If this principle rules out one, it has to rule out the other.— Blake Temple, distinguished professor emeritus of mathematics, UC Davis
Temple's point is not that Earth sits at the centre of the universe, but that the Copernican principle must be applied consistently: if it is used to dismiss spherically symmetric alternatives to Lambda-CDM, it should be applied with equal rigour to the standard model itself, according to the researchers.
What the paper establishes and what it does not are importantly different things. The proof covers a defined mathematical class of solutions — those with spherical symmetry and pressureless matter. It demonstrates instability within those assumptions and describes families of solutions that evolve away from Friedmann behaviour with acceleration. It does not, by itself, constitute observational evidence that dark energy does not exist, nor does it replace the need to match predictions against supernova distances, galaxy clustering and the cosmic microwave background. According to presda.com, a replacement model must earn its place through predictions that can be compared with independent measurements. Peer review places the paper in the scientific literature; it does not make every cosmological interpretation a settled fact.
The question of dark energy's nature is already in flux from the observational side. In March 2025, the DESI collaboration — using nearly 15 million galaxies and quasars — reported strengthened hints that dark energy may evolve over time, according to presda.com. That is a different hypothesis from a universe without dark energy, and it does not confirm the Alexander-Temple-Vogler model, but it illustrates that the standard Lambda-CDM picture is under pressure from multiple directions simultaneously.
The study was funded by the United Kingdom's Engineering and Physical Sciences Research Council and the American Institute of Mathematics SQuaREs Program. The next test for the theory is whether its geometry can be connected to light propagation and the full body of observational evidence that Lambda-CDM has spent decades accounting for.
Why it matters — If the mathematical proof holds up to independent scrutiny and can be matched against observational data, it would mean the universe's accelerating expansion — one of the biggest mysteries in physics — requires no new physics beyond Einstein's century-old equations.
⚠ Not yet confirmed
- The study received wider media coverage in October 2026, though UC Davis discussed it publicly on May 27, 2026.
- broad claim that the proof covers Friedmann spacetimes broadly (softened to specified class with spherical symmetry and pressureless matter)
Reported by sciencedaily.com, ucdavis.edu, timesofindia.indiatimes.com, presda.com
- Nicolaus CopernicusPolish mathematician and astronomer (1473-1543)
- Edwin HubbleAmerican astronomer (1889–1953)
- Saul PerlmutterAmerican astrophysicist and Nobel laureate
- Brian SchmidtAmerican-born Australian astrophysicist
- Adam RiessAmerican astrophysicist
- Christopher AlexanderAmerican architect and design theorist (1936-2022)